MovieChat Forums > Cadet Kelly (2002) Discussion > Another Disney Winner! Go Hilary!

Another Disney Winner! Go Hilary!


Sweet, funny and with a cute message.

Great messages for girls about being able to do anything (even the cheerleader types can succeed at military school and come out ahead!) and also about getting along with others. Hilary(as Cadet Kelly) is able to make friends and make up without being a 'suck up' --- she does her share of naughtiness before smoothing the way for friendships by being the one to stick her hand out first.

One of the situations that impressed me was when Hilary hurt one new schoolmates feelings as she ran into her old friend and introduced the old friend as her 'forever best friend'. She goofs then learns from her mistakes (hurting a friend's feelings) then goes back later and apologizes to her newer friend without 'taking it back' or lying, she admits what she said but says that she has known her 'other best friend' longer than her new best friend but that both are her best friends and she apologizes for being insensitive. Women of my generation weren't taught to do that!

Great Disney, super messages, we'd love to have this one on DVD!

reply

This movie doesn't rely on stereotypes, and yet it does.

Many have criticized the portrayal of military school and the many flaws of protocol represented in the movie. One that most civilians notice immediately is when Kelly polishes the boots of the drill team as punishment. Everyone knows that each cadet polishes his or her own boots, but in this case, the audience is willing to suspend disbelief because the punishment is worked into the storyline convincingly so that Brad can demonstrate the correct procedure.

The fact that a 14-year-old would accept her plight without more resistance is something that breaks the stereotype of a typical rebellous cinema teenager since the days of James Dean. She respects her parents, her mother's remarriage, the rights of the individual and strives to do right. She is socially conscious in her sensitive treatment of Carla in providing a dress for the dance, yet she doesn't realize that dress and rules conformity is the ticket of admission to acceptance in the military.

Only after making the drill team, does she have her epiphany that a person may seemingly lose some of her individuality as she becomes a part of something larger than herself when she catches siight of her uniform in the equipment room. Kelly has exactly the same realization that Henry Fleming had in the "Red Badge of Courage."

Another stereotype that Kelly dispells is that children will use their parents to bail them out. She doesn't rely upon her stepfather's authority, nor does she want to become overly obligated to Gloria who coaches her for the drill team tryouts. She knows that she doesn't know and figures out how to gain that knowledge by paying Gloria with her prized possessions. This is exactly what Frederick Douglas did when he "bribed" his white playmates to learn how to read.

This movie should be in everyone's top 250!



reply