MovieChat Forums > Irréversible (2002) Discussion > what's the point of the subway scene

what's the point of the subway scene


What's the point of the scene where the 3 protagonists are discussing their sex life during a train ride?
I mean it was already established that the ex still loved monica belluci

reply

I think the scene might want you to judge their personality especially Alex. Whether she should be raped (Sounds crazy, but if a girl is *beep* up like Amy in Gone Girl, why shouldn't they get raped), or whether you should feel compassion about her. The subway scene potrayed deeply when they're together and this will reflect the scene you just watched minutes ago. I know they're stupid to discuss the topic out loud publicly, but that's what the director wanted it to be. To depict your judgement of what you just witnessed the aftermath was tolerable with how their life were.

The other thing is because if you listened to their script meticulously, they said things like the need to focus during sex, the beauty of orgasms, the best man wins etc.

At one point Alex said, 'a man needs to focus on himself, not on pleasuring the partner. If a man needs to pleasure his partner, what he needs is to focus on his body motion to get his partner to feel what he's feeling.'

I knew when the dialogue came up, the first thing that bubbled in my brain was the retape of the rape scene. The man really pleasured himself until he had a good orgasm, so the subway scene also potrayed that she should get the pleasure even though she was raped intensely in a red light tunnel.

So the subway scene had two reasons.

reply

The gentleman who raped her really did seem to enjoy himself. It appeared that Alex's bottom was to his liking.

I'm a real kewl kat.🐈

reply

I would say Monica Bellucci's gorgeous, sexy ass is to every mans liking!!

reply

Apparently. And also it appeared that Alex complied with the gentleman's request not to defecate on his manhood during the steamy encounter. That is what probably saved her life.

I'm a real kewl kat.🐈

reply

This is gross.

reply