The ending was very blah
So after Madison dies, that's it for Ben's life? He's clearly not on the swim team anymore, not going to his dream college since Madison ruined that for him. So, we're supposed to believe that the happy ending is that he and Amy are back together? Clearly if Ben cheated on her, it shows there was something missing in their relationship to begin with. It doesn't seem like they really talked through what was in Ben's head when he cheated.
share