MovieChat Forums > Gods and Generals (2003) Discussion > The Angel Of Maryes Heights

The Angel Of Maryes Heights


I wish they had included a scene where CSA army private Richard Kirkland heard the wailing of the wounded Union soldiers at night, behind the wall, yelling for water, help, anything. He couldn't stand it, and asked his commanding officer for permission to go over the wall and take water canteens to the wounded enemy soldiers. He went back time and time again, risking being shot fro both sides. He was selfless in his act of mercy.

Soldiers from both sides were forced to listen to the painful cries of the wounded for hours, with neither side daring to venture out for fear of being shot by the enemy. At some point during the day, Kirkland approached Confederate Brig. Gen. Joseph B. Kershaw, also from Kershaw County, South Carolina, and informed him that he wished to help the wounded Union soldiers. By Kershaw's own account, at first he denied the request, but later he relented. However, when Kirkland asked if he could show a white handkerchief, General Kershaw stated he could not do that. Kirkland responded "All right, sir, I'll take my chances."

Kirkland gathered all the canteens he could carry, filled them with water, then ventured out onto the battlefield. He ventured back and forth several times, giving the wounded Union soldiers water, warm clothing, and blankets. Soldiers from both the Union and Confederate armies watched as he performed his task, but no one fired a shot. General Kershaw later stated that he observed Kirkland for more than an hour and a half. At first, it was thought that the Union would open fire, which would result in the Confederacy returning fire, resulting in Kirkland being caught in a crossfire. However, within a very short time, it became obvious to both sides as to what Kirkland was doing, and according to Kershaw cries for water erupted all over the battlefield from wounded soldiers. Kirkland did not stop until he had helped every wounded soldier (confederate and federal) on the Confederate's end of the battlefield. Sergeant Kirkland's actions remain a legend in Fredericksburg to this day.

reply

This sounds like the incident I have heard a quote from but I'm not sure who it was said by. The story, without names or which side it was, goes that one soldier ventured out to give water to a wounded soldier/s. Another soldier from the other side saw this and asked a nearby officer if he should shoot him.

The Officer replied "Don't shoot. That man's too brave to be shot."

reply

Indeed. The man the officer was talking about was Richard Kirkland, a confederate soldier in General Kershaws brigade who could take the moaning and wailing of the wounded men mere yards away no more. He requested once to General Kershaw, in person, to take a canteen and go over the wall to give blankets and water to the Union wounded. He asked General Kershaw of the Confederates if he (Kirkland) could raise a white hankerchif for safety, but was declined because Kershaw knew it would be interpretted wrongly by the Union. He asked to go anyway, and General Kershaw let him go. Richard Kirkland grabbed as many canteens as he could carry and blankets and coats, and hopped the wall. To the amazement of both sides, no one fired a single shot. And Kirkland continued this, going back for more water and blankets as he ran out, for an hour and a half. It was one of the most stirring things I imagine anyone on that field had ever seen.

Richard Kirkland would go on to continue fighting in General Kershaws South Carolina brigade, even surviving the battle of Gettysburg. However he was killed at Chickamahgua in 1863.

Heres a link to the wikipedia page about him:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Rowland_Kirkland

reply