Self-Defense


People on this board keep mentioning how the last scene couldn't be defined as self-defense. I don't see why it matters, because the protagonist defeated the antagonist, as we all like to see happen in the movies.

But I think that when they claim self-defense, they could be talking about more than just that one night. He kept tracking her down through the whole movie. He threatened her as well as people closest to her and whenever he was around her, he'd beat her. I kinda use the word 'beat' loosely because I'm not sure if I'd classify the first instance as a beating. Though it was still wrong and he should be castrated for it. I would think that a beating would be more like when she was trying to sneak out, like he doesn't stop hitting her, instead of a slap and a punch. But like I said, beating or no beating, he put his hands on her in a negative way and should be punished.

But back to my point, after everything he did, physically; mentally; and emotionally, to her she knew he wouldn't stop until he killed her. So even though she went to him and started the fight, she was still defending herself against all of the things he did, and all of the things he would have done, which would have ended in her death.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah I dont think that would fly anywhere. I belive the point was that even though she DID murder him. He couldnt exactly attack her in his condition right before she kicked him the last time.

The abuse she took in the beginning would likely make a fair cover for what she did. Besides I dont think she would have told anyone that she murdered him like that. Though calling her friend and actually telling her that she couldnt kill him was a REALLY bad move. It implicates her friend and tells her that she did plan on killing him..

That scene is pretty much everything that Krav Maga is against. KM is self defence but naturally its also very powerful for attacking. But its a last resort. Any fight youre able to walk or run away from is a won fight.

reply

[deleted]