MovieChat Forums > Ned Kelly (2004) Discussion > Where did Naomi Watts' character come fr...

Where did Naomi Watts' character come from?


I did not like this adaptation much at all. I haven't read Our Sunshine yet, does anyone know if the script follows that well? It certainly doesn't follow The True HIstory of the Kelly Gang by Carey, and that seems to be pretty accurate since it follows letters that Ned Kelly wrote (or dictated) himself.

Is Naomi Watts' character based on any real person? I loved Mary (I think that was her name, it's been forever since I read the book), whom Ned is in love with in the book. She was one of my favorite characters, and she ends up having Ned's daughter, so she's fairly important. How could they just leave her out?

I also wish that they had gone into Ned's childhood a little more. There were such unfortunate circumstances that made him into who he was. This made up more than half the book, yet was only about one minute in the movie.

I understand that a movie cannot be completely accurate, but it would have been so much better if it had been based on Carey's book. If they were going to make the movie, they should've waited until they could get the rights for that and made a better, more compelling and story driven movie.

Hate is baggage. Life's too short to be pissed off all the time.
American History x

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I read that they were told by some US company that if they wanted the movie to sell at all in the US they would need to make up a love interest.

reply

Naomi's character and the horse would have sufficed.

reply

Both Our Sunshine by Robert Drewe and True History of the Kelly Gang by Peter Carey are ficticious. Mary Ahern was not real, she was a made up character. Ned never sired a child (and if he did history is yet to reveal this to us) but our reality is Ned had no children.

Both Carey and Drewe have used historical events as a skeleton upon which to hang products of their imagination, removing some of the historical truth, and inserting events they imagined themselves.

I really enjoyed both the novels, but I read them understanding the context before I began. Carey's in particular was very well written. I will say though that calling it 'True History of the Kelly Gang' has misled lots and lots of people, so don't feel too bad.

If you are interested in the real truth of Ned's life, an historian called Ian Jones has researched Ned for over 60 years, and has written a factual book called "A Short Life". Get it on Amazon...it will answer every question you have.




And here's my offer to your counter offer. Go f--k yourself.

reply

The Black Lagoon

reply