MovieChat Forums > The Hours (2003) Discussion > 'Only I knew that she could disappear......

'Only I knew that she could disappear...'


When Laura is sitting on the toilet towards the end and discussing Kitty with Dan, she says she is terrified and when Dan asks why, she responds with "only I knew that she could disappear."

Does anyone have any insight on what this is supposed to mean? Like other quotes in the movie, it's a bit ambiguous to me.

I wonder if she means it as she is either worried Kitty will die ("disappear") or that she thought Kitty was possibly using the whole health thing as a front to up and leave, like Laura wanted to do. Or I could be way off base. Curious about your thoughts...

reply

Interesting. You're not the first person to ask that question on this board, but I always hear that line as "The thought that she could disappear" which makes more sense. I think I checked the subtitle last time this came up and that confirmed it, but I'm not 100% about that. My memory of it though is that that is a mishearing of the line, but apparently a common one.






Reality is the new fiction they say, truth is truer these days, truth is man-made

reply

I think it means she's scared Kitty may die. I mean, Laura was in love with her...

reply

I don't think Laura was in love with Kitty, she just admired her.




Reality is the new fiction they say, truth is truer these days, truth is man-made

reply

I don't think Laura is truly talking about Kitty anymore; Laura is talking about Laura. She is so deeply depressed, that she is terrified.

Her husband who loves her very much is somewhat aware of her illness, but doesn't realize the extent of it. I interpret the scene as having two conversations going on: Laura's own illness eating her alive (a conversation we don't hear out loud), and the very surface-level conversation about Kitty with her husband. It is almost painful to watch Laura force conversation and try to appear "okay." I imagine this is just one small glimpse of how every day is for her character: the chaos going on inside, and going through the motions on the outside.

That's just my interpretation though. I have depression as well, so I could just be projecting my own feelings into the movie. Interesting topic!

reply

Thank you for sharing your opinion on this scene and I'm sorry for the troubles you are going through.

I can see where you are coming from with your interpretation; it is clear that Laura is less engaged in the superficial conversation and more bogged down with whatever other thoughts are racing through her mind (thoughts of leaving, thoughts of not wanting to go on with life, etc.).

One of the things that is so amazing but so tragic about The Hours is all of the scenes or interactions that are really left open for interpretation.

reply