MovieChat Forums > Ararat (2002) Discussion > Article 301 is an Affront Against Everyo...

Article 301 is an Affront Against Everyone


I'm hoping that the young minds of Turkey are not represented by Ogun Samast (and his like), but by progressive thinkers who consider the subject matter of the following piece to be representative of the great shame that stands against Turkey. The Turkish members of this board must do everything in their power (by raising their collective voice and inviting others to join them) to rid Turkey of the atrocious Article 301. How can the Turkish people allow such idiocy to stand as a valid article of law? Please, tell me that (at least) the young generation of Turks are just as disgusted by it (301) as I am, or as any other freedom-loving, forward-thinking person would be.

Turkish Prosecutors Open Case into Dink's Funeral Slogans

ISTANBUL (Combined Sources)--The Prosecutor's Office in Istanbul district of Sisli initiated an inquiry into the slogans "We are all Hrant Dink," and "We are all Armenians," chanted during the funeral of the murdered Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, Turkish newspapers reported.

The prosecutor's office filed an application to the Interior Ministry to open a criminal investigation into the conduct of Sisli Mayor Mustafa Sargul and the organizing committee of the funeral.

A journalist working for a local Sinop newspaper filed a criminal complaint against the slogans chanted at the funeral. The journalist argued that the slogans at the funeral were racist and some insulted laws.

The complaint argued that a placard that said "Hrant's murderer is Article 301" was a clear insult against the Turkish Penal Code. The Prosecutor's Office needs ministerial approval to proceed with the criminal investigation against the mayor.

Dink was murdered by a 17-year-old on January 19 in front of the building of the Agos weekly, where he worked as editor-in-chief.

Article 301 criminalizes insulting the Turkish state, Turkishness, state institutions and Turkey's founder Mustafa Kemal Ataturk and it is criticized by the European Union and rights organizations as a barrier to freedom of expression.

A group of activists invited prosecutors to press charges against them on Friday in a protest against a law that restricts free speech and has been used to prosecute intellectuals.

Five members of the small Powerful Turkey Party stood in front of a prosecutor at a courthouse and repeated statements by Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan Pamuk, slain journalist Hrant Dink and other intellectuals that were used as evidence to prosecute them under Article 301 of Turkey's penal code, which bans insults to Turkish identity.

The group, including party leader Tuna Beklevic, then asked the prosecutor to file charges against them. Prosecutors would have to investigate Beklevic and his friends before opening any lawsuit, and none of the activists were arrested.

More members of the party, which has just a few thousand adherents in a country of 70 million, plan to conduct a similar act of civil disobedience next week.

Pamuk and Dink had both spoken out about the mass killings of Armenians by Turks in the early 20th century, an issue that remains sensitive today. Numerous other writers, journalists and academics have also been prosecuted.
Good for those who will see it (301) to its end.

reply

[deleted]

""We are all Armenians" was a genuine way of saying "We are all humans"."

Exactly!

reply

First of all, that criminal complaint was filed by one idiotic individual and he dropped back after the protests from all circles. Here's a link to his own statement about dropping the case, online published in his own online newspaper: http://www.haber57.com/yeni/readarticle.php?article_id=26
I'd translate it but it's not worth the effort. I'll give you the outline though: "I'm an opportunistic nationalist dick and I filed a stupid complaint but since I am a clown, I dropped it within 24 hours. By the way, I think my language is poetic."


Also Varlo, about the highlighted passages in your post: Tuna Bekleviç is an idiot of a young-white-liberal-jackal who is trying hard to be famous, using every opportunity and means that comes along. He made his name known through internet first, via immensely popular turkish dictionary-like website "eksi sozluk" (http://sozluk.sourtimes.org). And majority of eksi sozluk thinks he's a clown. Kindly trust me on this: he knows nothing about politics, he just wants to be known. Tomorrow he may enter Turkish Pop Star contest. He is a joke, so is his party.

And I second Vita es Morte about 301: It is going to change soon and be done with after the elections.

reply

"I'm an opportunistic nationalist dick and I filed a stupid complaint but since I am a clown, I dropped it within 24 hours. By the way, I think my language is poetic."
I'll admit that I laughed at this (humorous translation); but I got your meaning. My view of it is that it's good to know that others share the view that freedom of expression must be a given.

Kindly trust me on this: he knows nothing about politics, he just wants to be known. Tomorrow he may enter Turkish Pop Star contest. He is a joke, so is his party.
So, I take it that "Powerful Turkey Party" is a self-proclaimed title. Is that correct? (lol.)

If you mean that he protests just for the sake of protesting, I understand. I always question the sincerity of that type of protester. There has to be a true cause in every protest. One can't protest for the sake of protesting; it would bring one's integrity (among other things) into question.

I don't know of Beklevic (outside of this), but I'll take your word for it. :)


And I second Vita es Morte about 301: It is going to change soon and be done with after the elections.
If Erdogan relies on the "nationalist" vote, why would he do away with this article (after the elections)? Why do you suspect (or believe) that the nationalists would allow/accept this?

reply

"If Erdogan relies on the "nationalist" vote, why would he do away with this article (after the elections)? "

Exactly , especially now when people are bitter towards the west - the armenian genocide , Kurdistan , Cyprus , no EU entry in sight etc ...

Welcome to the Christian Board

( bashing-free )

http://com5.runboard.com/bshjihm

reply

Varlo, Tuna Beklevic is the antithetic of sincerity. "Powerful Turkiye Party" (GTP) should be named "The Great Spam Party" considering the amount of trash mail they keep sending if they get hold of your mail. GTP might get %0,01 of all votes, half of it stamped by mistake. I give you the proud leader of GTP, Tuna Bekleviç the Seahorse (party amblem): http://www.gercekgundem.com/img/news/tuna.jpg


If Erdogan relies on the "nationalist" vote, why would he do away with this article (after the elections)?

The answer is simple, unfortunately: Because nationalist will forget about 301 by the next elections, within approx. 5 years. The 301 article will change, that's for sure. I think non-governmental organizations already have a consensus about how it should change but I don't know about when. But we would like to see it gone, permanently.

From what I see from the media, I think Turkey's new foreign policy this year, until november (elections) will be solely based on Kurdistan, North Iraq.

Besides, we have another important election coming up: the presidency elections within the parliament. And everyone knows Tayyip is literally desperate to be elected. 2007 will be a year of turmoil for us...

reply

[deleted]

Nobody gives a crap about Turkey

No contradiction here. Mak is a nobody and he cares a lot about Turkiye. Hey, hate-monger, how's hate-monging going?

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

"Also Varlo, about the highlighted passages in your post: Tuna Bekleviç is an idiot of a young-white-liberal-jackal who is trying hard to be famous"
I have never heard about him and his party before.Looks like he has a long way to go.

reply