MovieChat Forums > Frailty (2002) Discussion > Lame movie that glorified crime in the n...

Lame movie that glorified crime in the name of 'God' !


The movie, and its technical aspects were all great. But the movie fails miserably, at least for me, in desperately trying to glorify crime in the name of 'God'. When did man become so stupid and brainless? Isn't that's what portrayed in the movie. Anyone who comes talking to me about God's will and sort, I'll kick their ass. Lame retarded religious fanatic morons !

Anyway, I rate this movie 6/10.

My Favs: Hurt Locker, A Beautiful Mind, Schindler's List, Inglourious Basterds

reply

It was a supernatural movie, it didnt glorify crime at all. Nobody says that about Goodfellas and that was largely based on a true story, and what about the Saw series? These are movies for entertainment purposes, if its something thats going to influence someone to go out and murder people because of what they saw in a movie, then that person was already never right in the head.

reply

I don't think this glorifies crime. Because:

1.) the killers believe they're destroying demons, not killing people. And acknowledge that killing people is bad. The father literally said all that. More than once, I think. As in the crimes in this film are portrayed through two point of views: the right-minded who purely point it out as bad, and the delusional minded who also point crime out as bad and believe that they're not doing crime. Every character and event is saying killing is bad and wrong, and the film takes a mental illness approach to have them keep doing it anyway.

b.) the one time the father knowingly killed a human, he did it crying and literally threw up right after it.

c.) The father brutally killed people in front of his 10-year old and 13-year old children, and even though one of the boys begged him not to. And even though the younger boy was btainwshed/delusional/childlikely beliving in whatever his father told him, he was nonetheless a little boy watching his parent butcher people. And he clearly wasn't enjoying any of it no matter what he believed his father was doing.

How does any of that glorify crime?

Plus:

d.) the supernatural twist could basically be said to glorify crime, but I daresay most people don't take it like that. Non-believers certainly wouldn't give a crap about God's involvment but simply think murder is wrong. And any healthy believer is likely to live by one of the Ten Commandments that say "you shall not kill". As in, the real world's popular mythology, God has literally made killing one of the greatest sins. Therefore "God told them to kill these people" twist in a fictional story justifises it in its own fictional universe but fails to justify or glorify the kills for the viewer's universe.

reply

6 out of 10 is "lame"?

It doesn't glorify crime either, IMO.

It's one of the best psychological horror movies of the 21st century.

8/10

reply

Calm down OP. It's just a movie.
I very much doubt it had any religious or sociological agenda.

reply

Sounds like the OP needs some mental help and needs to be medicated and has deep seated issues with religion/religious people. OP sounds crazier then any of the characters in this movie and should seek help if a Hollywood movie evokes that kind of strange reaction of wanting to commit violence against religious people.

reply

Way to totally miss the point. This is fiction, it in no way attempts to justify murder or glorify it in real life.

The new home of Welcome to Planet Bob: http://kingofbob.blogspot.ca/

reply

I agree with frozenlantern.


"That's like putting your whole mouth right in The Dip!" - Seinfeld

reply