MovieChat Forums > Frailty (2002) Discussion > Was anyone else offended by this movie?

Was anyone else offended by this movie?


I'll start off by saying that I thought this was a well shot, well acted film. I thought that it started off well. The backstory was suspensful and made you think "What if?".

The message that I got from the ending was that there really are demons and angels and that Adam and his father could see them. This is evident by the fact that as soon as Adam touched the agent, the agent could not defend himself and had succumbed to the "power of god", the fact that no one could see the faces on the tape, and could not recall Adam's face. Regardless of the fact of whether he and his father had made up the other backgrounds of the "demons", Adam was made to seem correct.

Is the director telling us that there are in fact, demons and angels? If so, this is not only unfulfilling and sanctimonious, but it is a real cheat for the script.

Please someone write whether I just got the wrong take on this movie and maybe I am incorrect, or if this what one was supposed to take this movie as...

reply

I don't know if "offended" is the right word, but I didn't like that it went from being essentially a skeptics' film into a believing one. I like a good twist but this one felt like it had an agenda.

"Passion is just insanity in a cashmere sweater!"

reply

[deleted]

Yeah I stopped watching because there isn't much bible *beep* I can stand.
I like some fantasy movies but not like these.

Love is gender-less, sex is for procreation. Miauw run off and have a lovely time.

reply

That's exactly what offended me about this piece of *beep* film. Horrible message, and it basically condones, more or less, that kind of thinking. At first I thought it was going to be a serious critique on the horrors of religious zealotry, but no, then it's 'true' and they really are evil people doing bad things. What BS.

reply

This movie is the most morally vile I've ever seen.

Of course, it's pure fantasy. But there are religious zealots out there who probably masturbate watching this delusional tripe.

----------------------
http://mulhollandcinelog.wordpress.com/

reply

Okay, I read quite a bit of the older posts in this thread, but many are simply not getting the basic points of this movie. Here they are (as far as the story in the movie is concerned): MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS

1. God IS real.

2. Dad did receive a real vision from God about killing DEMONS, not people (will explain).

3. In the Bible, Angels and demons can take on human form (I am not talking about possessing a real human being), and the movie is suggesting that in the last days, as the movies suggests it is, there are demons walking around AS humans, but are NOT humans.

4. God gave Dad and Adam the ability to detect these demons to verify their true nature and imbued their common tools, like an axe, with supernatural ability to actually DESTROY the demons that had taken on human form. They were NOT killing real people, except, apparently, for the Sheriff who dad killed to keep their secret. That is why he was so repentant for doing so and sick to his stomach. It may be, in that case, he did not trust in God and acted out of fear of exposure, when, in fact, God would have blinded the sheriff to the "killings". IT is also quite possible that, since they were really demons, there would be no bodies left, but who knows?

3. Fenton was, in fact, a demon, somehow born to humans, but he WAS s demon in human form, and he was supposed to have been destroyed. He, as a demon, ended up killing human beings.

Now, this is all a movie, and not how God operates, but, just like movies where there really are vampire killers or zombie killers, these truly, in the movie, were demon killers.

I hope this clarifies the very clear story in the movie.

reply

Yes, agreed on all points.

It is funny how so many people seem to have ignored the part of the film where Fenton and Adam's dad stated these were demons, not humans who did bad things. They were demons who took human form -- so if what the dad said was true, and it would appear it was based on what the movie showed, then this wasn't about giving bad people their due, otherwise they could just go out and target everyone who did a bad thing, rather than wait for God to give them a list.

Fenton saw them as normal people, because he was a demon -- so the viewer saw them as normal people, too.

As you said, this was just a film, and within the story of the film this was not a case of good people killing bad people. It was a case of demon killers killing demons -- not humans who committed crimes, demons in human form.

reply

It was a case of demon killers killing demons -- not humans who committed crimes, demons in human form.
That's right, and in this case "demons" would just mean non-believers or defiers of "God" and not beings who commit evil acts.. both the "God's Army" and the "Demons" did evil and this was just a war about who was the strongest one.

reply

"But there are religious zealots out there who probably masturbate watching this delusional tripe."

Kinda like the atheist zealots do to the propagandaist filth churned out by people like Bill Maher, Seth McFarlane, Ricky Gervais, Sarah Silverman, etc...


+++by His wounds we are healed. - Isaiah 53:5+++


reply

It's just a movie and it is stupid to be offended by it. What makes me wonder is why, when there is any mention of God in anything, atheists feel the need to tell people how they feel offended. Why should it offend you if someone believes in God or a movie has religious tones in it? I'm sure you watch movies about all kinds of subject matter, but I doubt you posts on those boards about feeling offended because you don't believe in, for example, aliens, vampires, or zombies. Maybe you should ask yourself why it bothers you in the first place because it speaks volumes to me.

reply

Okay so you were offended...... now what?

reply

the irony of OP taking this movie seriously enough to be offended by a fiction piece... kinda fits the what movie was saying in the first part... it's just a brilliant movie that touches the important subject of what people choose to believe, but the movie goes beyond that and ends with borderline tong-in-cheek humor... it's a 10/10 movie

reply