MovieChat Forums > The Pianist (2003) Discussion > Why did everyone work so hard to save Sz...

Why did everyone work so hard to save Szpilman??



I saw a post up here that said that musicians were rather highly valued then, but still. He was just a local pianist, wasn't he?
Its wonderfully warm-hearted that they did this. But they risked their lives & spent lots of money & time to save a locally known pianist, one man?
He wasn't a politician or a priest or someone well-known.

I'm just curious.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

They were part of the Polish resistance against the Nazis from what I gathered, plus he was their friend.

reply

Friendship,dude - a beautiful thing . He was an assimilated Jew therefore had many non-Jewish friends. Poland lost a huge number of Jewish and non-Jewish intelligentsia, therefore it was a priority to protect them to save the cultural heritage.

There are channels on youtube devoted to pre-war schlagers. Some aficionados who collect these old records often give details about the fate of the creators. From that alone you can see that many perished - among them Artur Gold, the composer of top chart tango hits. He was gassed in Treblinka. His brother Henryk, also a composer, fled like another famous one, Jerzy Petersburski, to the Soviet-occupied part of Poland - both survived the war. A song writer, Adam Wlast, was hiding on the Aryan side but, unlike Szpilman, couldn't psychologically handle his ordeal, walked out on the street and was shot by a German patrol. My favorite singer of that era, Tadeusz Faliszewski survived Mauthausen-Gusen concentration camp.

I love this tango "Happiness should be devoured like fresh cherries" sung by Faliszewski:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8o7JEhZ9Sg

"Last Sunday" tango by Petersburski

This beautiful, sentimental tango was often played as a mockery in concentration camps by the Jewish orchestra for people going to their deaths.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-hg58QQmdc

reply


Henryk survived?!
I seem to recall that both the film & the book stated that Szpilman lost his entire family.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

I wrote: Henryk Gold, Arthur Gold's brother(both were very famous pre-war composers) not Henryk Szpilman.

reply


Sorry, my mistake.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

I personally know the Szpilman family and have been to their home in Warsaw. Henryk died, as did all of Władysław Szpilman's immediate relatives. He is survived by a widow, Halina (nee Grzecznarowska), two sons, and two grandchildren. The only blood relatives of Władysław Szpilman who weren't killed in Treblinka were an aunt who immigrated to Argentina before the war; some other distant relatives had immigrated to Brazil and France.

As far as why people were so willing to help Szpilman, there are several reasons. I highly recommend the book "The Secret City: The Hidden Jews of Warsaw" by Prof. Gunnar S. Paulsson. The author argues that 28,000 Jews had escaped the Warsaw Ghetto, 11,500 of whom survived to see the city's "liberation" by the Red Army. The rest were killed by Germans, denounced by their Polish neighbors, died of starvation, died during the city-wide Warsaw Uprising, or fell victim to the Hotel Polski scheme. Paulsson estimates that, on the Polish side, there were 70,000-90,000 helpers of Jews, and 3,000-4,000 blackmailers. He claims that those Jews who had the best chance of survival were those who most likely to find helpers and survive were: 1)Assimilated (remember, in Poland at the time most Jews spoke Yiddish as their primary language and were not well-integrated into Polish society) 2)Had friends on the non-Jewish side of the city 3)Spoke good Polish 4)Looked non-Jewish. Except the last factor, Szpilman met all these qualifications. He didn't consider himself to be a Jew, but rather a "Pole of Jewish origins" (he married a non-Jewish woman, and his children were raised Catholic) and his family didn't speak Yiddish or practice Judaism. He was a fairly well-known person in pre-war Poland due to his role on Polish Radio, and was already becoming a celebrity: he wrote many popular Polish songs and wrote the scores to two popular pre-war Polish films. Szpilman himself estimated that about 30 non-Jewish Poles helped him during the war. Of course, this is a testament to these person's courage and nobility, but also to the fact that he had many friends on the Polish side, and could easily pass as a non-Jewish Pole.

reply

Back then, the radio was the thing. He was well known all over poland from being on the polish radio.

Think of it this way, if Rihanna or whoever , was in the same situation, wouldnt u help? Tina turner? Even a NFL player.
He did have lots of friends and was very well liked.
In his memior, it explains it more in detail.

reply

Here's my view on the question (from a personal review)

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0253474/reviews-764

Again, don't expect a hero à la Oskar Schindler in Wladislaw, "The Pianist" shows the boldness of a period where cowardice was sometimes guided by survival instinct, where the desire to live could be more necessary than the desire to fight, because surviving left more voices to speak about the atrocities. "The Pianist" reveals those hidden subtleties that couldn't be truly expressed in epic movies. Some Jews didn't fight back precisely because the horrors of Auschwitz, Treblinka, Buchenwald had to be known, and ironically, this was one of the reasons that accelerated the exterminations' process. And some like Wladislaw had to hide not to make the sacrifices of the others unnecessary, those were tough times and no one is allowed to put a judgment... not us, anyway.


"Darth Vader is scary and I The Godfather"

reply