MovieChat Forums > Life with Judy Garland: Me and My Shadows (2001) Discussion > who else was listlessly depressed after ...

who else was listlessly depressed after watching?


It's so sad and the girl that plays young judy breaks your heart...judy davis makes you sad cause it's old judy and old judy's all depressed and not cheery any more. What a sad life.

Did you know that vodka comes from a potato?--Bette Midler, Down and Out in BH

reply

No way. I was sad when Judy died but after it showed her singing "Get Happy" and Lorna saying that she was not a tragedy I was fine, because Judy did not live a sad life. She lived a life filled with happiness and sadness but with so much more happiness. The sadness was not who she was, Judy could always come back and said near the end of her life "I've had an awfully nice life"

reply

See, even though Lorna says it wasn't a tragedy, and yadda yadda...I was still pretty depressed after watching this...It's one of my favorite movies, because it's so well done, but it's still a very sad story...

So, I would have to agree with the original poster.

~Joan of Arcadia Fan FOREVER~

reply