Your Impressions of Edith...


Even though there have been tons of film versions of Anne Frank's story, I don't think we've really gotten a good look at who Edith Frank really was. Don't get me wrong - I thought she was portrayed very well in this movie by a wonderful actress, and I understand that it must be very difficult for writers to capture every detail of her life and personality with so little existing information about her (the majority comes from Anne's diary, which can be pretty one-sided, for obvious reasons). But, I think there's much more to her than what we see onscreen and read about in the diary. With that in mind, I was wondering...what are your impressions of her (personality, marriage, youth, etc.)?
Personally, I think that, in her youth and into her adulthood right around the time she met Otto, she was a lot more like Anne than Anne liked to think (although these traits obviously became stifled within her, quite unlike how they clearly appeared in Anne). After reading Anne's diary, quite a few of her descriptions of her mother stuck out to me. She mentioned that Edith was "unfeminine," and spoke of her "slipshod ways." These descriptions hint that, at one point, Edith probably had higher ambitions than being a housewife alone. However, I think that she pushed those ambitions aside when Otto came into the picture, as taking the housewife route seemed the right thing to do.
Later, I think much of the behavior that irritated Anne came from many sources: a sense of helplessness in the Annex (she tried to get Otto to take the family to America early on and later told Miep that she felt their situation was hopeless), feelings of frustration and sadness about her unreturned love for Otto, and, perhaps, the fact that she saw in Anne the qualities that she used to have and that she missed about herself (which could explain her behavior toward Anne in particular).
Anyway, that's a little bit of my impression of her...I'm looking forward to hearing everyone else's!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

No doubt about it, she loved them both very deeply (especially to make such a sacrifice for them). As important to her as they were before the arrest, they really became the center of her world during their time in Auschwitz - even after Anne and Margot had been sent to Bergen-Belsen. It's too bad that it took such extreme circumstances to prove to Anne that her mother did love her, despite the tension that always seemed to exist between them.

reply

[deleted]

I had always pictured Edith as being a modest, overly-conservative, uptight house-wife, but come to think of it-- if I had kept a diary when I was 13, that is probably about how my mother would be portrayed too. Most 13 year old girls are going to be critical of their moms and aren't able to understand the sacrifice and love that their mother is constantly giving. If I got grounded, I would see my mom as a mean witch who didn't want me to have any fun, rather than a caring person who wanted me to learn from my mistakes. Since then, (even though it was only about 4 years ago), I think I've grown up a lot and have learned to see my mom as a person and a genuine woman who truly wants what's best for me. I wander if Anne was a few years older if her perspective would be a little bit different. Their is no doubt in my mind that Edith loved her unconditionally and without measure.

Also, if her and Otto's marriage wasn't the happiest ever, that could have caused her to be more uptight and stressed than her natural character would have been.

reply

well said. I did keep a diary when i was 13 and i wrote horrible things about my mum. Teenaged girls generally dislike their mothers at that time and argue ALOT. It probalby has something to do with hormones too. I seemed to have so much hatred for my mum at that age and through most of my teen years. Now as an adult i see her for what she is. A good mum, though flawed (as we all are), who always did her best.

Although Edith isn't portrayed as being very affectionate, i don't think there is any doubt that she loved her daughters.

it's a shame that we only have Anne's perception of her. I mean, we get snippets from Miep Gies and others in interviews, etc. But it's a shame that there is not more information on Edith, or any of the other occupants really.

reply

I find her depressing: very plain and low in spirits. The kind of housewife you would expect to take drugs in order not to buckle under the pressure.

reply

One of the things I find most depressing is the way most people always seem to overlook her and don't really seem interested in getting to know her better. Even in Anne's diary, there are only a few entries devoted just to her, so, just based on that, it's really hard to find out much about her. It makes me so curious about who she was and what she did, and I'm trying to find out all there is to know. It's very challenging...it's like most of the things she did in her life are unknown so far.
I got to play her in a local production of "The Diary of Anne Frank" about a month ago, and it was a completely amazing experience. That especially made me think about her as a person and how little we really have been told about her.
So far, I've read a few Anne Frank biographies and, of course, the diary, but if anyone has any suggestions of where I can get good information about her, please let me know. Thanks!

reply

That's why I don't want to be a housewife: you leave no legacy.

reply

I don't particularly think she didn't leave a legacy. I just think there are a lot of details about her (especially her young life) that we don't know yet.

I guess the legacy thing is all in how you look at it. To me, she led an amazing life just based on all that she did for the welfare of her children alone, not even considering the other things that she may have done with her life.

Hey, maybe she felt the same way about becoming a housewife and we just don't know it because of all the missing details about her life before she married Otto. I wouldn't be surprised. I think we still have a lot to learn about her.

reply