I have a couple of questions about the movie. I plan to read the book eventually (I've heard it's quite good), but these questions are about the movie in particular:
1. When Becky went off with Jos in the end, was that another scheme to improve her position or did she genuinely want to be with him and go to India?
2. What was the meaning of Rawdon always sulking in the background?
3. Was that Reese Witherspoon's singing voice?
4. If George wanted to marry to spite his father, couldn't he have married someone else whom he liked and of whom his father didn't approve? Why would he marry Amelia if he felt so burdened by her?
5. When Rawdon was walking out and Becky said that she had made a mistake, was she being honest or was she just trying to manipulate him?
6. George was a captain. Why would he not know what was going on when the bugle sounded at the ball? Could you become a captain if you are, as Rawdon described George, "green"?
One more:
7. I was a little confused about the state of Becky and Amelia's friendship throughout the movie. Were they friends throughout? Their relationship seemed strained at times. Did they go through a time of not being friends, then reconcile? Near the end, Dobbins said that Amelia would not want to see her. Before that, Amelia was angry at Becky for dancing with George while she (Amelia) was alone.
Please, don't tell me what happened in the book. I do plan to read it and I don't want too many spoilers. Thanks in advance.
"I'm the best there is at what I do, and what I do best isn't very nice." -- Wolverine
2. He was upset at the attention Steyne was paying to Becky and was jealous that she seemed to be enjoying it so much.
3. No, her songs were dubbed by a professional singer by the name of Custer LaRue.
4. It was one of the very few good deeds that George did when he stood by Amelia. He had promised to marry her and felt honor-bound to do so and didn't think it right to throw her over for someone richer, no matter what his father said. He then went on to resent her and neglect her after their marriage, but still had a brief moment of decency and affection for her that caused him to stand by her.
5. In the movie, I think maybe it's a combination of both. She does seem to have some affection for Rawdon, but I think mostly it's that she realizes her behavior may have just cost her everything and she's saying whatever she can to avoid losing it.
6. At this time, the rich would buy commissions, or positions in the army. So a man with no experience at all but the right amount of money and connections could become an officer. In 1796, about 19 years before the battle of Waterloo shown in the film, the Commander in Chief of the army had begun a series of reforms to the army--prior to that, one could buy any officer position, including general with no experience, which led to completely incompetent and inexperienced senior officers and meant the army was in a bad way. With the reforms, one could still buy their way up the ranks, but you had to serve a certain numbers of years in the position below; so one would have to have been a lieutenant for 3 years before they could become a captain. Nonetheless, Dobbin isn't saying George hasn't had experience in the army, but that he's green in that he has never actually been in a real battle yet. And it's not that George doesn't know a bugle means to assemble, but that a bugle at a ball like that would mean big news and so he's asking what the news is. As shown by the amount of people in Brussels and enjoying themselves at a ball, the British forces were taken by surprise with the speed of Napoleon's forces and were not expecting his army to be so close.
7. Amelia had been the only person who was truly kind to Becky when she was poor and had no one else. Becky, whatever her other faults, did not forget that kindness, and so they did stay friends for a long time, although they were completely opposites and had nothing in common and often couldn't understand each other. Amelia isn't so much angry at Becky dancing with George, but at this point, Amelia and George had only been married a few months. George is already resenting Amelia and treating her abruptly or neglecting her, especially the night of the ball when she feels terrible and didn't want to come (but he makes her come anyway, and then completely ignores her once they get there). And before meeting Becky in Brussels again and before his marriage to Amelia, George had disliked Becky and thought her a money-hungry social climber. So Amelia is hurt that George is treating her with coldness, but treating her friend warmly, especially when he supposedly couldn't stand her friend. After Rawdon leaves Becky, the word gets around why, that she's supposedly having an affair with Steyne. Becky becomes a social outcast, her reputation tarnished, and no one, not even Amelia, would brave social convention to befriend her. And Amelia strongly believed in a woman being pure and virtuous and social standards and all that, so she was shocked and appalled at the idea of Becky having an affair or even the appearance of having an affair. So Amelia stayed away from Becky after that and and they don't see each other again until after Becky meets Jos in the gambling house 10+ years later.
Come, we must press against the tide of naughtiness. Mind your step.
1. you don't know that. considering her situation at the moment, and the fact that she practically gave up all hope, i think she saw Jos as some kind of savior. This was no scheme, it was totally unplanned and unexpected.
4. agreed. I would add that i think it was more about pride, that doing the right thing. and if you think about it, the right thing would have been for George to do exactly what his father wanted him to do. She would have suffered for the moment, but at least she wouldn't have lived a lifetime of illusions.
5. I think she trully loved him. It's just that the guy failed to do what a man must do: provide. Who can blame her? Seriously, she had a kid, and the guy never provided.
7. I loved the grey in this movie. I think it's like in real life, a friendship has it's ups and downs. Sharp is lovable, but then she does some bitchy things out of the blue. The world is all but a web of interests, no principles whatsoever, verry, verry few clean good characters, Amelia and Dobbin, and they get a lifetime of missery for believing in that fairy-tale love. I was bothered by the happy end, i didn't think it was in the spirit of up-to-then story. I thought that the message of the story (at least up to the end) is clear: the world is evil, and love sucks.
I don't mean scheme in that she had been planning this for the last 10 years, but that she saw him again, she's in desperate circumstances, he had almost caved earlier when she tried to scheme her way into marriage with him and he's still easy prey. I don't think it appeared like her feelings for him had changed at all, it seemed like she was still putting on the charm to get what she wanted but I didn't see much feeling behind it. In the book though, it's extremely clear that she is using Jos. In fact, he dies in somewhat suspicious circumstances soon after he and Becky get together (and Becky conveniently inherits what money he had left, although they hadn't married), and Amelia and Dobbin believe Becky may have "hastened" his death through some means like poison.
Come, we must press against the tide of naughtiness. Mind your step.
5. I think she trully loved him. It's just that the guy failed to do what a man must do: provide. Who can blame her? Seriously, she had a kid, and the guy never provided.
Well, going by the novel, I strongly disagree. Becky only married Rawdon for his money. She would have happily married his father instead. In fact, when Lady Crawley dies and Sir Pitt proposes to her, she wishes she were not already married to Rawdon because then she could have been Lady Crawley.
5. I think she trully loved him. It's just that the guy failed to do what a man must do: provide. Who can blame her? Seriously, she had a kid, and the guy never provided.
I forgot to mention in my post above that Becky knew Rawdon's situation when she married him. As the younger son, he wouldn't inherit property nor title. Second sons had to make their way for themselves, but there were only two respectable "professions" for a gentleman: army/navy officer or clergyman. They achieved these professions usually with a leg up from a relative who might purchase them a commission in the army or buy them a preferment in the church.
According to society's rules, Rawdon wasn't permitted to earn a living any other way. If he became a merchant he would be shunned. It's pretty obvious that Becky wanted to reach the upper levels of society, so she knew what the options were before she married Rawdon.