MovieChat Forums > Looking for Alibrandi (2000) Discussion > Great cover of With or Without You

Great cover of With or Without You



This sing is so haunting and eerie, i believe its by a guy called Hamish Cowan, but its funny that this song is in it and at a point in the movie a bus goes past and on the side its advertising U2 The best of 1980-90 album, pretty funny.

God is punishing me for being Atheist.

reply

Ooh, well spotted!

Hamish was once part of an Australian act called Cordrazine. You can read more information about him at the following link:

http://www.amo.org.au/artist.asp?id=95

reply

*Plot details follow*

Yeah, it is a great cover. It suits the scene more than U2's version would've. It's so touching when, at the end of the song, Jacob comes and gives Josie a hug when she's so down.

I can't keep holding on to what you got when all you got is hurt...

reply

Nah I Reckon That U2 do A Better Job Than A Cover Band. The Movie Is An Absolute Masterpiece and should never be remade!

Anyone For Plum Jam?

reply

im not saying it is better, only its a great cover. Its hard to do a version of such a great song by the greatest bank in the world! Just giving praise where it is due...

The water is warm until you discover how deep.

reply

i cant even listen to that song now without thinking of this moving and then tearing up!!! man im sucha chick haha

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

This was my favourite part of the movie!!!
Soo sad and such a beautiful song.

reply

that song makes me cry i love it though


-i can't believe it! they f-!#ing forgot my birthday!-
i love mr darcy- dammn that motherchucker!

reply