If you did, which part makes you cry?
For me, it was when the six St. Anthony's boys pick up John's coffin, and are all trying to hold back tears. So sad...
Any others?
May'07- Mullroy and Murtogg are BACK!
Captain Jack Attacks(Even tho noone missed him)
well thats the part that had me in tears aswell!!!
that song 'with or wihtout you' (cover version)
is so fitting to johns situation
when her nonna explains how her husband treated her i got sad too but i didn't tear up
-you bleed just to know your alive-
[deleted]
Yep where they're walking with the coffin and 'with or without you' is playing. And when Josie is wondering about the sheets, whether they'll throw them away or scrub them until they're clean and sleep on them every night.
... And John's letter.
lol yeah that was sad too. all the boys in my class were laughing. cos we gotta read the book 4 english then we watch the movie. the books borin.. but its lol..
all the boys were holdin back tears..
that was cute.
i felt so shocked when they told josie. it really got me. and then the when the boys were trying not to cry had me trying with all my might not to cry also (we were in health class!) it was so incredibly tragic and then the music.. just powerful.
shareI hated the whole part to do with John's funeral and him dieing and her finding out. it was sooo sad!!!! me and my friend were sitting on my bed crying as we were watching it..it was so sad.
my brother came in and was like..errr?? and i'm just like the movie..
:P lol
Xx
ZAYLEY.
ZAC+HAYLEY.
I LOVE ZAC.
for me it was when she broke down on the train and jacob comforted her...so sad!!!
shareThe whole With Or Without You scene kills me...even more so since my dear friend committed suicide last year.
Go take a step outside - see what's shaking in the real world.
The whole funeral scene to me is over-rated as an emotional aspect. Its a funeral. Easy tear-jerker. Its SUPPOSED to make you cry. I think its the more nuanced scenes in the story that show the emotion. For example, For me it was the scene just before the end where her father says if he goes to Adelaide, she can come and visit and she says if he stays, she'll visit him everyday. The catch of the sob in his voice as he goes to hug her. Far more emotional and note-worthy to me.
share