MovieChat Forums > Gangs of New York (2002) Discussion > Is that a real part of the history of U....

Is that a real part of the history of U.S.A ?


Watching the movie , I wondered : is it a real history or just imagination ?


Who can help ?



History forget a lot of heroes . I got the feeling that to be a hero , you need to be lucky .




..........................................................................mosash

reply

It is definitely a real part of history...bill the butcher...tweed..all the gangs. ..were real people. Theres a documentary called "the real gangs of new york" that explains alot of the history of that period. Part of why i loved the movie was it was based on real people n events.

reply

Some of the events and characters are based on real people and things that happened, though facts are changed and things fictionalized for the sake of entertainment. Things weren't quite this violent back then, for one. The gangs were more like political groups who kept their fighting limited to the polls, generally. They did get the persecution of the immigrating Irish portrayed well, though. The riots were real, though again not accurately portrayed. They were actually worse than the movie showed, but the real events didn't go well with the story. They were disgusting and racially driven, it wasn't just because people had to go to war, they were worried about freed slaves taking jobs, which led to an unknown amount of death.. So, it's a movie, not a documentary, but I think it sparks a lot of interest in the past.

reply

So, it's a movie, not a documentary, but I think it sparks a lot of interest in the past.
For instance I loved the way the Five Points location was recreated, in the main on a Rome sound stage, but just looking so realistic.🐭

reply

The set design was great, same with the costumes. I guess when your Martin Scorsese you get to have among the best in the business working around you.

reply

I agree the look of this movie is wonderful.

reply