MovieChat Forums > Enemy at the Gates (2001) Discussion > American college students---clueless and...

American college students---clueless and indifferent about World War II


I teach a Foreign Business Practices course at a State University. I recently watched this movie, and the other day I brought up the subject of World War II to my class. I was appalled and dismayed by the almost total lack of knowledge among the young adults in my class about even the most basic facts about the war. Only half of my 25 students could even venture a few confused facts about the war. Here is a sampling of some of the more jaw-dropping comments:


The Germans were our allies and the war was fought against Russia.

Either JFK or Eisenhower was president during the war.

Not a single one could name any of the leaders of the "Big Three" allies in the war. They thought "Stalin" was the name of a foreign car!

It took place in either Korea or Vietnam, (they thought).

The Chinese bombed Pearl Harbor.

The number killed during the war was "a few thousand or so".


These are young people who are going into business careers that will take them overseas. What kind of impression are they going to make when they go to countries like Russia and China, where memory of World War II is still very much alive? And profess a total ignorance of it? They're going to look like idiots!

Worst of all was the obvious disinterest they displayed in learning anything about the history of the war. The most titanic conflict in human history, and it's epicenter was Russia. And these young adults know almost nothing about it---and care about it even less!



reply

Feel better?

reply

Same question to you...

Condescending prîck.

reply

I'm calling *beep*

reply

This is the result of the government making sure people who have no business going to college end up going to college.

reply



At least fifty percent of them, probably more, belong in trade school to become plumbers or carpenters or cement workers.

reply

Says someone named I.B. Black. Love the irony.

reply

There is a good reason that university used to be just for a small percentage of the population...

Conquer your fear, and I promise you, you will conquer death.

reply

At least they didn't claim that Hitler was still alive.

American students are scary.

reply

Hitler was a Communist, right? 

reply

Yeah, we should be grateful that they didn't say Hitler was a commie and tried to save the jews from the Nazi Oskar Schindler...

Could have been worse.

reply

"The Chinese bombed Pearl Harbor. "

Come on -- everyone knows the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor and it was not over when they did!

reply

Considering it was the greatest conflict in Human history that is pretty sad. The U.S. played a vital role in the defeat of Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. That conflict makes today's so called war on terror little more than a bar room brawl.

reply

How often does the subject of WW2 come up in Russia and China? Yes, there are young people who know very little about the war, but there are also quite a few that know a lot about it, like my oldest son. Is he an expert? No, but neither are you. Painting an entire generation with one wide brush is quite ignorant.

reply

This is the result of poor culture of education, with the intent being to keep children as stupid as possible so they don't think too much for themselves and learn the true meaning of WW2, which was not just a battle to kill people and win, but a battle of ideology to determine the way mankind will live for the next 100 - 1000 years.

reply

BOOM! Nailed it!

reply