MovieChat Forums > Roswell (1999) Discussion > The person playing Liz is SUCH A BAD ACT...

The person playing Liz is SUCH A BAD ACTRESS


Good god, she's horrible. Why would they cast her? She has no real emotion, can't deliver her lines properly. It's just cringe worthy to watch her. I hope she's gotten better at acting but I'm currently on Season 1 and it's so hard to concentrate when she's on screen and talking. UUUGHH. The person playing Matt is bad too. Not as bad as this Applebee person, but still as bad. The other three characters can act. That Michael guy, Isabelle, and Maria are all decent. I have no idea why they chose those two to play the main roles when they're both the weakest at acting. Barf.

reply

You know she used to bother me too, but as the show goes on and the conundrums start piling up you just get used to her. By the time I got into the second season I thought she was appropriate.

Just wait until you start watching the episodes with Tess, now she's Irritating- but the kind of character she plays, that's also appropriate.

reply

I completely and utterly agree! They BOTH bug me to death! But I just accepted them as annoying and paid attention really only to the others! I LOVE Michael and Maria!

reply

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but I think she is amazing. The chemistry between Shiri and Jason is excellent aswell.

reply

Kevin (who went on to "Alias") implied that she couldn't walk and talk at the same time. She got the role because she was a cute girl.... which the show needed.

www.jrichardsingleton.blogspot.com

reply

Whose Kevin?

reply

Kevin Weisman. He plays the UFO nut who's there in the first episode when Liz gets shot. He also comes back for the convention episode.

#I'll be courageous if you can pretend that you've forgiven me.# Savage Garden

reply

Wow, he said that? That's harsh. I enjoyed Liz Parker and Shiri is one of my favourite actresses, she's doing awesome work in UnREAL right now.

reply

Do you have a link for this?

That's funny because he's kind of one note himself. I'm used to him and kind of liked him because he was in a few of my shows but he really shouldn't talk.

reply

That sounds like a typically mean thing some men say about some pretty girls and women even if it's not really true. I wouldn't take what he said about one pretty girl as gospel. And that guy strikes me as just the type of a-hole who says that kind of thing about a person who doesn't necessarily deserve the harsh assessment. I know the type.

Personally I think Shiri's ability to play this role was just fine, and right for the role. The character is a total Mary Sue who isn't meant to be much more than the perfect, sweet girl the guy falls in love with. She didn't have much to work with and she did just fine being what this role requires.

Emilie De Ravin on the other hand -- horrible actress, no skills, amateur.

reply

I actually liked some of her acting choices. Particularly her facial expressions. Like the stolen glances. Looking at the corner of her eyes. She did a lot of subtle stuff that I thought was great. Emilie De Ravin on the other hand was pretty wooden. Same thing with Brendan Fehr. That guy had a default 'acting' setting: frustrated. Although it might have just been because of the material he was given. Michael was always so whiny and emo. It was Majandra though that stole the show.

-------------------------------
-Pearls before swine-

reply

I agree on Emilie and Majandra.

reply

I loved Shiri as Liz in Roswell. She had this way of bringing you into her story: you felt her heartbreak , pain, joy, excitement. She conveyed these emotions so well with her facial expressions and mannerisms. Its hard for me to find an actress that does that. They just dont go "there", if you know what I mean. And her chemistry with Jason was amaze-balls.



I’m Liz Parker and five days ago I died. But then the really amazing thing happened. I came to life.

reply

I don't think she's bad at all. She plays the character perfectly.









"That's not what making out sounds like. Unless I'm doing it wrong."

reply

I think all the actors played their parts very well. I think you may be confusing the actors with your dislike for the characters those actors were portraying. I found Liz and Max's relationship a bit overbearing at times, and downright annoying at other times (mainly due to overly manufactured drama by the writers), but I still think the actors delivered great performances.

Or if you're a younger person and are used to today's WB/UPN teen OVER-acting, then yeah, I can understand you thinking Jason's and Shiri's subtle acting back in the late 90s not good in your eyes. I however (and I'd think many of Roswell's fans), would agree that their acting back then was much more realistic than the acting in any current teen dramas on network tv right now.

reply

Maria is who bugs me. But it's not necessarily the acting. I'm watching it for the first time in 2015 and I just can't believe how unflattering her hair and General style are. I lived through that time, that hair was never cute. Butt more importantly, I hate the writing for her character. The third episode about her potentially freaking out and telling the sheriff about them was just stupid. I mean, it was painful to watch but that wasn't the actress' fault.

reply

Boy are you in for a treat in season 2! When I started after season 1 I was like damn!

reply

I find Liz irritating in S1 but she comes into her own in later episodes. During the whole Alex storyline she's the only likeable character of the bunch, and Shiri got to show different acting chops because Liz grew a backbone and had some plot action separate from (and at odds with) Max. Before that all she got to do was play the cute vanilla girlfriend writing Disney love songs in her lame journal.
I liked her episodes at boarding school too, especially where she gets drunk, she's pretty funny in that scene, and her final scenes with Tess in S3 were actually some of the most poignant in the whole series, IMHO. Liz's passiveness also gave stronger characters like Maria and Isabel plenty of room to do their kooky/bitchy/melodramatic thing.
It takes a special kind of actress to play sweet and innocent convincingly without appearing like a flat one-dimensional Mary-Sue. Once Liz matures a bit and is more world-weary, tough and resilient, Shiri pulls it off. I always enjoy it when Liz shows a rare moment of snark or arguing back, like when she tells Max to wake up to the fact that he's controlling, or shoots an equally snide remark back at Tess when Tess is trying to talk down to her. It gives her character depth.




The mirror... it's broken.
Yes, I know. I like it that way. Makes me look the way I feel.

reply