It was an interesting idea. Casting younger lookalikes with some makeup was a good idea since in the era before CGI became as common as it is today you were never going to make those old geezers look like they were in their 20s. Overdubbing the voices was a neat idea about how to connect the characters. But the problem is that older men don't sound like they did 40 years ago. So you have these young guys who look like their older counterparts talking with "old guy voices." Epically with Eastwood and Garner, because we know what they sounded like 40 years earlier and it wasn't how they sounded in 1998.
Perhaps a more effective solution would have been to get some sound engineers to pitch and otherwise doctor the voices to sound younger or even to bring in some impressionists who could better sound like a "young Cline Eastwood/Garner/ect" and overdub the voices that way.
reply
share