MovieChat Forums > Ringu (1998) Discussion > How come the phone didn't ring for the e...

How come the phone didn't ring for the ex husband?


In the American one, the phone rang after Rachel's ex saw the video. How come it didn't ring when Asakawa's ex saw it?

Still don't know the explanation for this.

reply

[deleted]

Oh ok. I guess that makes sense.

If you remember the part in Ringy where Asakawa is interviewing the young girls about the cursed videotape, they are talking about what happens when you watch it. But I guess these are just rumours spreading around and to set the mystery of what actually the video is all about, and because the rumour has spread, no one is entirely sure what actually happens when you watch the video, since these people who are talking about it didn't watch it.



reply

That's one of many reasons The Ring is far better.

Your chains are still mine, you belong to me! - The Phantom Of The Opera

reply

I wouldn't say that makes it better, just different.

www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=6751188
www.originalfool.us

reply

[deleted]

I know this is an old topic, but I've just seen the original for the first time. Asakawa waited outside while Ryuji watched. He came outside to get her when it was over. Maybe the phone rang while she was outside, and we just didn't hear it?

Savvy?

reply

Hmmmm somehow I don't think so.

If you look at tvguy's response - I think it makes some sense. When Asakawa's niece describes the call she was also at the cabin as she had watched the video there too.

Though I don't know about those who watch it who are far away - they don't get the call then?

Perhaps I should read the original novel and it would provide more insight.

By the way - do you like this version of the American one better? I actually think they are both good in their own ways.

reply

As I write this, I realise that I don't recall Yoichi getting a call either. So perhaps there is something to be said about the distance from the cabin.

I've read the book (bought it in Japan, actually!), and it's a little different to the movie. Without giving too much away, the characters of Asakawa and Ryuji exist, but have been changed somewhat in the movie. It does reduce the number of characters and makes the storyline run smoother. Yoichi is based on another character, but doesn't exist in the book as he is portrayed in the movie. But to be honest, I don't recall specifics about the phone calls from the book. I'll have to get it out again.

I enjoyed both versions. As you say, they're both good in their own way. Though I found the Japanese version didn't have the same theatrics as the American one, which I did prefer. The Japanese one was more of a "slow burner" whereas the American one had a faster pace.

Savvy?

reply

Do you know is there is an english version of the book? I would buy the original - but I can't read Japanese lol

If you've seen the Ring 2 - both versions, I actually found the sequel (the Japanese one) a bit disappointing and not very chilling. I think because it went into scientific explanations more rather than the supernatural.

The American sequel was not in any way scary at all but was more like a psychological thriller that focused on the whole 'wanting to be a normal kid with a mummy' theme.

reply

I got it in English - you should be able to try Amazon. http://www.amazon.com/Ring-Trilogy-Koji-Suzuki/dp/1932234411

Haven't seen the Japanese version of the second movie. I'm not sure how closely it follows the book, but a lot of the second book (Spiral, if you're interested in reading it) was more about puzzle solving than the supernatural.

Savvy?

reply

I also think that the phone rang, but Ryuji has hidden the truth because he didn't want to worry Reiko. He was pretending that nothing has happend just to prove that the story about killer video tape is all made up.

reply

I've just finished watching the film, so it's fairly fresh in my mind right now. As other people have suggested, the phone only rang for Asakawa and the four teens because they were in the cabin.

Near the end of the film, Asakawa gets a phone call telling her that they can't find any information on where Sadako went after leaving the island. After that call, she looks up at a phone and says something like: "It didn't ring at my house," referring to when Yoichi (her son) watched the tape. Her realisation that the phone only rang at the cabin is what makes her realise that Sadako must have moved out there.

So the phone didn't ring for Asakawa's ex because he wasn't at the cabin when he watched the tape, which is also why it didn't ring for Yoichi.

x-caitlin-x

reply

Correct, and it's important to notice that the lack of phone call increases the surprise of the viewer for the final twist, unlike in the remake...

Juliet Parrish: You can't win a war if you're extinct!

reply

This guy gets it.

[evil9]Chaos, panic & disorder.... my work here is done.[evil9]

reply

There is also the rumor at the beginning of the film of the other, unnamed little boy who supposedly took a trip to Izu, had a recording made in the cabin while he was out playing, and took it back home to watch it. He supposedly got a phone call AT HOME.

There supposedly was also a spoken message to him over the phone, too.

Although, it's possible that this was only a false rumor, expanding upon true stories that did take place within the cabin. Details get mixed up in the rumor mill, like that.

Tomoko's story matched up with Reiko's insofar as there NOT being a voice on the phone line after the video played in the cabin.

Were there any phone calls when people saw videos or contracted the curse/virus away from the cabin in any of the other Japanese Ringu films?

I wonder why Sadako would be limited from making phone calls away from the cabin, when she could clearly crawl out of televisions and electrified swimming pools, and instill visions in people's heads at long distance.

reply

There is also the rumor at the beginning of the film of the other, unnamed little boy who supposedly took a trip to Izu, had a recording made in the cabin while he was out playing, and took it back home to watch it. He supposedly got a phone call AT HOME.

There supposedly was also a spoken message to him over the phone, too.
Just a rumor. The phone rang at the cabin for some people, so those who heard the rumor but hadn't experienced the event itself simply assumed the phone rang anywhere you happened to be.

"The comfort of the rich depends upon an abundant supply of the poor."
- Voltaire

reply

My theory is a Little different, the phone only rings once at the start of a curse. If you pass the curse on, by copying the video and showing it to someone else the phone will not ring again because its only an extencion of the first Curse!!

reply

I think he actually did receive a call because a view moments later when he arrives at his ex wife's house the ex wife asked what was wrong with him because he looked frightened. I think he got a call when his ex was gone. Sorry I can't remember those names :0

reply

I think he actually did receive a call because a view moments later when he arrives at his ex wife's house the ex wife asked what was wrong with him because he looked frightened. I think he got a call when his ex was gone. Sorry I can't remember those names :0
No, the phone only rings right after you watch the video, not some time later. So he didn't get a call; it only rang at the cabin.

He was unnerved when he went to Reiko's apartment because he had just seen and felt the apparition of a woman, probably Sadako, when he was sitting on that public bench.

"The comfort of the rich depends upon an abundant supply of the poor."
- Voltaire

reply

The novel is more in-depth about the telephone. The explanation is fairly simple, and others have sort of mentioned it.

Only those who watched the video in the cabin above the well where Sadako is got the phone call. Her power only extended that far. Those who saw the video away from the cabin would not receive a call.

reply