Embassy Combat Scene a Joke


We see Marines running around, making themselves easy targets and being shot, then running around some more still in a fashion that made them easy targets, being shot up more. Meanwhile they never return fire, never attempt to ID the whereabouts of the snipers firing on them. The Marines in the movie firefight generally act like arcade game targets.

If there was a Col. Terry L. Childers, he should have been court martialled for incompetence on this point alone. But then, in another bit of implausibility, we see a full colonel where we would more likely see a 2nd lieutenant or even a non-com in command.

And we are further asked to believe that this situation would even arise. The embassy would have its own Marines, would have control of its own external security and not be entirely dependent on the Yemeni government. A quick, organised surprise attack could overwhelm things outside the embassy temporarily, but not for hours on end. Embassy security should have been able to handle the crowds and snipers the movie shows after an initial attack. And the movie shows no evidence they even tried this.

And the Yemeni government withdrawing their troops? Embassies are located in capital cities. If a government can't control their own capital city, they can't be a government. Maybe they withdraw troops in the case of a full out civil war. But in doing so, they violate their own sovereignty and then invite the U.S. to do the same. Wouldn't happen.

reply

You can actually say that witha straight face? I'll grant the first part of your assessment is fairly accurate but thats it.
We've dealt w MANY hot extractions of Embassy staff. Yes they have a Marine contingent but its not overly large. In several places we had to go in and get our people out.
For you to say can't happen is lĂ ughable. Benghazi, Somalia, Iraq, a number of other locations have all experienced Embassy attacks.
Please read up a bit on this and you will see just how hairy it can get. Embassy duty is not always safe duty.

reply

[deleted]

yeah, the whole "marines running around, not identifying any of the shooters on the rooves" is appalling. They show the marines to be a bunch of incompetent buffoons.

And that's not even bringing the hilariously aged Tommy Lee Jones and Samuel L. Jackson back in the Vietnam segment. Not attempt made to hide their incredibly advanced aged faces, except perhaps for Tommy Jones' brimmed hat offering some shade at the beginning there.

...HOW old are these guys supposed to be in the "present day" segments?? Tommy Lee Jones' character has VERY young-looking parents, and a what, 20 year old son?? Call it a vanity project, jesus.

reply

From 2012:

>And the Yemeni government withdrawing their troops? Embassies are located in >capital cities. If a government can't control their own capital city, they can't >be a government.

Right now as we speak insurgents are doing this very thing in Yemen...

...and Mrs. Taylor sure seems to use a lotta ice, whenever he's away

reply