MovieChat Forums > South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut (1999) Discussion > Parker and Stone's biggest mistake...

Parker and Stone's biggest mistake...

posted 15 years ago by radicalrick
14 replies | jump to latest

The flm itself is great, especially as a musical. But in all honesty, surely everyone can agree with me that Trey Parker and Matt Stone made the biggest mistake of their lives by not killing off Kyle's mother in this film.

She was such a bastard, manipulated everyone into making everything go her way, contradicted herself by telling kids not to swear before she did that herself and yet she survived the war. Fat ugly maniplative old hag she was.

And why didn't more South Park characters have speaking roles, like the chrildrens' fathers, Officer Barbrady, the Mayor and so on and so forth? What gives?

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] simontottle 15 years ago

Yeah, killing her off would be the stupidest thing to do. Can't believe the stupidity that went on in your head to want kyles mum to DIE.. she's an incredible character, her portrayal as the stereotypical jewish mother. You missed the trick of trey and matt's genius here.

[–] aaa001 14 years ago

You are a *beep* idiot for starting this post. You clearly have not watched much South Park.

[–] radicalrick 14 years ago

You listen to me aaao001, I have actually watched plenty of South Park, since 1999 in fact. I just felt this was an issue that could do with bringing up. As far as I'm concered, I'm not being an idiot actually.

As for the rest of you, maybe you're all right in that killing her off might have been a daft thing for Parker and Stone to do, but it would have been for the good of the town. However, I can assure you that it wasn't stupidity going into my head to want that to happen, because there have been various other characters like her from other TV shows or films that I wanted to see dead but never occured.

[–] Muinaiset 14 years ago

"As far as I'm concered, I'm not being an idiot actually."

This is pure gold. Thanks for the laugh, dumbass.

http://www.last.fm/user/OBLIVIONxSPAWN

[–] MrBook_ 14 years ago

You listen to me aaao001, I have actually watched plenty of South Park, since 1999 in fact. I just felt this was an issue that could do with bringing up. As far as I'm concered, I'm not being an idiot actually.

As for the rest of you, maybe you're all right in that killing her off might have been a daft thing for Parker and Stone to do, but it would have been for the good of the town. However, I can assure you that it wasn't stupidity going into my head to want that to happen, because there have been various other characters like her from other TV shows or films that I wanted to see dead but never occured.

How DARE you make an argument without saying that other people are idiots and losers and they should kill themselves. Consider your internet priveleges officially REVOKED. Take your "reason" and "relative politeness" and "capability for rational thought" and go hang out in the real world with the other weirdos.

Get on up.

[–] guywhowatchesmovies 14 years ago

Wow, simontottle and aaa001, you guys need to chill. Dude's just giving his opinion.

[–] plasppus 14 years ago

Seriously...She might be Muff Cabbage but thats whats great about her. Shes one of the best characters you absolutely love to hate. And they did the music in an amazing way so I totally disagree there too.

[–] donstuie 14 years ago

Besides, she was never the same character after this movie anyway. She softened up big time after this.

[–] canad-ian 14 years ago

lol I wouldn't say Mrs. Broflovski softened up but yeah OP you're being dense.

"Skank!! You sank my destroyer!!"

[–] hiphopfanatic 14 years ago

Just watched "It's a Jersey Thing," and I have to greatly disagree with you OP.

[–] Trinadtsat_Tomitsu 13 years ago

"She was such a bastard, manipulated everyone into making everything go her way, contradicted herself by telling kids not to swear before she did that herself and yet she survived the war. Fat ugly maniplative old hag she was. "

If that was enough of a reason to kill off a character then Cartman would have been killed more times than Kenny by now.

[–] Penske_Material 12 years ago

And why didn't more South Park characters have speaking roles, like the chrildrens' fathers, Officer Barbrady, the Mayor and so on and so forth? What gives?

well that would;ve been a horrible idea, that's why The Simpsons movie wasnt that good, they made a plot where they could throw in together all of the characters instead of focusing on a more original idea for the movie, and the result was I'll admit, an enjoyable movie but, very predictable, not in the sense that i knew how everything was gonna happen, but Homer ruining and then saving the day was something i bet most people could've guessed, and that was the only way to give almost every character a speaking role, which was at the same time their worst mistake.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=_w1ogaJ16hc

[–] ZabyPS3 12 years ago

I can't believe no one has said this yet...........

'WHAT-WHAT-WWWWWWHAT!?!?!'

an almost George Lucasian (!) fit of ass hattery