100m cut is worse than theatrical
Ok, I have not seen the 7 different versions, or each version from every county in Europe, or whatever is available.
I have seen 1)a DVD from a college library, and 2)the 100 minute version on Netflix.
The Netflix version is excruciatingly worse than the DVD copy I saw several years ago. Quick list of problems:
1) At least 12 minutes longer. Slows the pace to crawl.
2) Way too much pontificating from the overacting villain, a lot of that was not in the first cut I saw.
3) Added horrible gay double entendres. "You want to be in me?" And they threw that into Connor's mini-speech thru Duncan at the end. What the crap? Really stupid. If I'm going to kill the man who murdered my mom and daughter over several hundred years, I'm not going to make a gay joke and a bad callback to "Call me" in the span of 30 seconds. Makes a potentially epic moment very campy. Also, they screwed with the Duncan/Connor face melt somehow. Made it look worse and mean less in the moment.
4) Kate lives?!?!?!? Dafuq? Kell was a monster who killed Kate in the first cut I saw. The ending with Duncan alone on the mountaintop was very moving. Why do a 180 and add a stupid reunion/make-out scene and explain it as "Kell made his choice."? His choice? What choice? To completely undo his entire character MO, for a happy ending? Beyond horrible.
The 100 minute cut was boring, very poorly paced and edited. Made the actors appear to give worse performances and talk too much. Added crappy dialog, thematically inconsistent conversations, ruined the ending, emasculated the villain for the sake of a good ending and betrayed the whole point of the movie!
If revenge doesn't grant redemption, why does killing Kell get your wife back?
Ugh so bad.
The worst part is I recommended to some friends that we watch the Netflix version unaware it was not the decent movie I saw years ago. Made me look dumb. Jerks.