MovieChat Forums > The Boondock Saints (2000) Discussion > I dont understand the N word scene.

I dont understand the N word scene.


The scene where the one dude was telling a joke or a story and said a black dude was something something. the guy listening to the story was like. No say N word. i dont even know why they did that. it added nothing and made the movie only be awkward to watch if you have some black friends.

reply

I think it was to reinforce the fact that Rocco had no business in the business. He was terrible at his job as errand boy (as judged by the terrible sandwich) and he just doesn't have the same views as the 'big boys' do.

reply

It's a staple of gangster or crime movies. Scorsese started it and Tarantino carried the torch. Now if you have a gangster/crime flick set in the United States it's seen as "unrealistic" not to include it.

----
I'd love to see you in the moonlight with your head thrown back and your body on fire.

reply

Italian mobsters hate Black people that's why they made him use the slur rather than address them more PC.

reply

Because it sounds a lot better than "black person".

reply

The boss and the sub-boss knew that "the funny man" was not a real gangster (in their eyes) and they were already planning to set him up (remember the hotel room scene after when they basically sent him to get killed by the Russians).

So the point was to basically make him uncomfortable and show themselves that he's not like-minded. The Italian mafia is typically portrayed in films as being very racist against blacks in particular.

I agree that it's awkward to watch but I think that's intentional as well. Sort of put the viewer off a bit to try and simulate the tension that Rocco felt all the time while posing as a gangster etc.

Reading my signature constitutes admission that I am correct. (Too late)

reply

You mean when they say *beep*

reply

If people these days are driven to the point to be unable to appreciate the humor in that scene because of feeling awkward out of political correctness, that's really a shame.

Maybe it's just easier for people like me who don't live in a country with African descended minority, but, come on... You can laugh and cheer at Quentin Tarantino's anti-white racist trolling, but can't appreciate this one?

This is one of the most hilarious scenes in the history of cinema - papa Joe involuntarily (or not) interrupting the feud between Rocco and the guard with a burst of Italianizied insults, *insignifiC@nt* "BASTARDO!" , "Tell me a funny joke" and that look lol, acting totally uninterested in the joke except for a correction to "A NI99ER!", pointing at his sandwich mid joke and making the "come on what is this...?" expression, and finally, putting his sandwich away, looking dead serious with his comedic face and staring at Rocco - "Continue the joke." with an Italian accented hard "o" in continue lol.

That last line immediately became a cult line in our group of movie fans back in 2000-th and we didn't even had a clue that the film will gain so much followers with the years to come.

_______________
Is it sexist to hit you? Is it more sexist not to hit you? The line is so blurry!

reply



OK, that scene wasn't great, he told a bad joke poorly, is that part of the comedy, I don't know. I didn't get much humor out of it. Thankfully it was a short scene.

But it did have Ron Jeremy it that scene, and that lended to the film a level of gravitas, you have to admit that fact.

Also, I loved it when the underboss unwrapped the hoagie and it had hardly any meat on it, he was pretty displeased, and I definitely related to that aspect of the scene.

But if the N word made it awkward to watch if you have black friends:

1. Would it not be awkward to watch if you did not have black friends?

2. Would it be less awkward to watch if your black friends were not present than if they were?

3. Are the N word scenes in Pulp Fiction, upon which this film is apparently modeled, awkward to watch, with or without black friends?

reply

pulp fiction had black people as main characters in the movie and the dude that said it was also married to a black woman. I also would more likely watch the boondock saints with friends and not pulpfiction. I felt the white guy in pulp was not racist but just mad at what they brung into his garage. I dont know what he could have said besides dead N'word storage that would have fit. Dead person storage just sounds dumb.

reply

I didn't mind that scene. Just because Italians are racist and the joke is a little funny to me. "You mean to tell me that all the beeps and beeps are out of America?" "Yes.' "Well, I'll have a Coke then."

reply