MovieChat Forums > Dune (2000) Discussion > The Barons sexuality

The Barons sexuality


I'm curious as to whether in the novel that it's ever implied that the Baron is gay or at least bi-sexual. In the 1984 David Lynch version of the book there was a definite gay subtext while in this version it was practically confirmed. So was there or was it something that Lynch just added and the mini-series followed up on?

reply

No, his homosexuality is depicted in the book. The scene in the mini-series where Feyd tries to kill the Baron by slipping the poison needle in the slave boy's thigh was lifted right from the novel.

reply

Thanks.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

He was homosexual since he liked young 'boys.' If he liked young girls, then he would've been a heterosexual pedophile.

reply

The Baron was depicted as completely homosexual, although he is sadistic and perverted and likes to inflict pain on anyone.

***Maybe a spoiler below***

In the first of the prequels, House Atreides, it is explained that having sex with Mohiam to conceive Jessica was an horrendous task for him. He was utterly disgusted by the woman's soft forms compared with the male muscles he liked

reply

[deleted]

Of course he was homosexual. I am not sure, either, of the mutual distinction implied between homosexual and pedophile.

Glad you touched on the point from the prequel ... atrocious stuff. I guess they liked some of Lynch's changes, though.

reply

Actually, statistically pedophiles who prey only on young boys are more often otherwise heteroseuxal in terms of their relationships with other adults.

reply

[deleted]

Damn the prequels, atrocious works.

Fortunately we don't have to rely on them for this.

Paul to Jessica while they are fleeing to the Fremen:

“You’re the Baron’s own daughter,” he said, and watched the way she pressed her hands to her mouth. “The Baron sampled many pleasures in his youth, and once permitted himself to be seduced. But it was for the genetic purposes of the Bene Gesserit, by one of you.”

reply

Baron Harkonnen is a sexual sadist whose tastes run to boys/young men.

reply