MovieChat Forums > The Sopranos (1999) Discussion > Bobby was a made guy without ever killin...

Bobby was a made guy without ever killing anyone.


How does that happen?

reply

Getting made isn't about murder count. Its about money. He must have earned alot.

reply

didn't he?

reply

Tony made him kill that guy at the laundromat, in Canada -- after he bested Tony in a fistfight.

reply

That was his only kill the whole series.

reply

It's not necessarily a rule that you have to kill someone to be a made guy. If you're a good earner, and are well liked by the guys, and probably have some good family connections (Bobby Sr. was Juniors top button man for a lone time), then you could get made.

reply

he was made before he came on the show. maybe he killed before he was made. but I can't recall if it was ever discussed that he never killed anybody. I am re-watching the show and am on season 3, episode 6.

reply

Yes, it was discussed with Tony while at Bobby's lake house. Tony directly pointed out that he never whacked anyone. Bobby says, "I did a lot of other shit, but . . . "

reply

thanks.

reply

I like to think that the fierce and imposing Bobby we saw in last season was the one who existed before he was assigned the wet nurse job to Uncle Junior. We also saw hints of Bobby's breaking point early on when Tony laughed at him in his hunting attire and said "Fuck This!". I was surprised by his reaction, but when Jr. told him to obey Tony he followed orders nonetheless. That showed me that he could turn on a dime and execute top brass orders better than most of the other members that Tony gave bigger assignments to.

reply

So, killing someone is supposed to be part of the entry fee because that shows you aren't a cop and can be c trusted to do whatever is necessary.

Do we know if Bobby ever kill before the series started?

reply

Please see RickGee’s comment on this above. No, Bobby had not whacked anyone as was discussed between Tony and Bobby at the lake.

I think Sandman81 (also above) gave the best explanation of how Bobby probably got made without clipping someone.

reply

Y’all missed the point.

He wasnt made to because he had lineage, that being his father. And it never was an entrance fee. I think Chris hadnt necessarily be made to.

reply

Bobby was probably the smartest of the group. And I don’t mean in IQ only, but in EQ as well.

The others were either too stupid, too emotionally unstable or too drugged out.

These defects caused them and Tony to lose thousands of dollars.

Bobby was smart, emotionally stable and didn’t use drugs. He didn’t even have a goomar. That last one alone saved him a lot of problems.

So, Bobby was the most trustworthy of the crew.

reply