MovieChat Forums > The Astronaut's Wife (1999) Discussion > What a shame! (lots of spoilers include...

What a shame! (lots of spoilers included)


From about half way through, where the film should have been more and more exciting, it felt more and more like a drama about an abused wife.
There were gaps in the story, or at least I saw them as gaps.
There were story bits which didn't make much sense to me.
Why was that guy fired? There were only two hosts, nothing to make us at any point think there was a conspiracy going on reaching the NASA administration.
Were the radios at home special made? IF yes, by whom? If no, they waited for who knows how many years for communication to arrive...yet it was instantly available to them?
What was the vehicle of the aliens? If they were as mentioned, just traveling through signals, then where were they when they waited for the astronauts to come? Why didn't they just go to the targets on Earth and waited for them to go in orbit? If the alien was just signal, WTF was it doing with the physical form near the end?

The wife believed in the theory behind her husband way way too easily.

At least the ending was cool, not perfect and not well acted, but cool. I mean, the kids were bad and not too happy with Charlize's performance, but her husband did well.
I do wonder though, how was the death of her husband explained to the police.


With small changes here and there, the movie could have been much better, but it's not.

reply

I wish, too, it had been more Invasion Of The Body Snatchers and less Rosemary's Baby, but what can you do.

The agent was fired because he acted like a lunatic. Jillian believes him almost right away because of what happened to her friend, and because she too heared the static and was doubting her husband already.

I like to think Spencer and Alex just happen to be up there in the wrong moment, at a wrong time. It wasn't planned, the aliens just took the oportunity. I wonder if they were some kind of explorers, last survivors of a dying race looking for a new home, or their race just roam the space looking for places to colonize.

reply

From about half way through, where the film should have been more and more exciting, it felt more and more like a drama about an abused wife.
I agree. The film started well and I liked the focus on Jillian, but then it just begins to flounder, mainly because there is just no real sensible back story for the aliens actually being here and "their planned invasion", which quite honestly seemed to me to be more appropriate for a an episode of The Simpsons.🐭

reply

At best, it's an interesting failure that had the potential to be much better.

Those are often the best films to remake. Wouldn't be "ruining a classic".

reply

[deleted]