MovieChat Forums > The Siege (1998) Discussion > The Siege or Red Dawn?

The Siege or Red Dawn?


Which movie was a br attack-on-America movie?
Which one is more believable?
Red Dawn (original or remake) or The Siege?
Discuss, or just cuss...

reply

Not even close comparisons and utterly REDICULOUS!! This movie was almost spot on predicting 9/11 tragedy which I watched unfold (not on the news!!) and is a movie on a very true subject which happened to be spot on . Red dawn was just almost a comedy compared to this. It was a fun movie and but a most rediculous scenario which could never happen. To compare the two movies is apples and sports cars (I use that cause they are sooo much different they cannot even compare even close on the same radar.. Not saying this angrily but just befuddled at the post

reply

a most rediculous scenario which could never happen.


It was based on CIA and War College studies of US weaknesses at the time. I guess watching 9/11 unfold(not on tv) makes you an expert on all things government and political. BTW, how was 9/11 like this film in anyway except the Muslims?

reply

If you mean Red Dawn 2012 than that movie is *beep* don't waste your time.

reply

Two fine movies. Red Dawn (original) was less believable which made it more fun.

reply

The Siege

reply