MovieChat Forums > Treasure Planet (2002) Discussion > I was expecting Jim to blow Scroop's bra...

I was expecting Jim to blow Scroop's brains out


as with Israel Hands.

reply

Well, I didn't expect Disney to show it explicitly but still...death by space?

reply

Can you seriously see somebody getting their brains blown out in a Disney movie?

Supermodels...spoiled stupid little stick figures mit poofy lips who sink only about zemselves.

reply

'Well, I didn't expect Disney to show it explicitly but still...death by space?'

Its a matter of irony. Scroop was responsible for Mr Arrow's death which happened in pretty much the same manner. It was fitting and just that Scroop should die the same way.

reply

theido: "Its a matter of irony. Scroop was responsible for Mr Arrow's death which happened in pretty much the same manner."

Except Arrow was sucked into a black hole and Scroop just... spun away.

Come to think of it, so did Darth Vader at the end of the first Star Wars film, but he came back.

reply

Except Darth Vader was in a space fighter and Scroop was just himself.

reply

Scroop, when you think about it, is going to suffer greatly - unlike Arrow, who would have been killed very quickly when Scroop kicked him off into the black hole, Scroop is going to starve to death floating out in the Etherium...possibly very slowly depending on his species' dietary needs.

Either way, can't say he didn't get what was coming to him.

reply

They didn't shy away from it in the 1950 version (also released by Disney). In that, Jim shoots Israel Hands in the face (as he does in the book) and you see it. It's virtually bloodless, but there's no mistake about what happened. Also in the 1950 version they make it clear that Silver's actions cause Mr. Arrow's death. But that was 1950.


A young girl passes / in a hurry. Hair uncombed. / Full of black devils. --Kelly Link

reply