MovieChat Forums > October Sky (1999) Discussion > Book vs. Movie (SPOILERS)

Book vs. Movie (SPOILERS)


I just got the book a few days ago and have zoomed through most of it, and I will say the book is very readable in its own right and also significantly different in many ways from the movie.

A few major differences:

1) The time frame. In the movie, the storyline is apparently spread over one school year, September (Homer getting his butt kicked in football), to May-June (launch of final rocket). In the book, the storyline stretched for about three full years (fall 1957-spring 1960).

2) The amount of help Homer/Sonny gets from his dad. In the movie Dad does nothing to help Homer until the very last night of the national science contest; in the book he does quite a lot to help him (including diverting some company resources).

3) In the book Sonny does not quit school to support the family after Dad's injury (in the book he only misses a week or so of work)

4) As others have pointed out, the number of "Rocket Boys" -- in the book there are six kids involved in the rocket building.

5) In the book many more details are given on Sonny/Homer's romantic exploits with the opposite sex.

6) In the book the rivalry between Homer/Sonny and Jim is much more nasty and bitter. Jim basically acts like a complete tool for the whole book.

7) As an outgrowth of that, "the football boys" are depicted throughout the book as villains. Although there are a couple scenes in the movie where the football boys pick on the rocket boys, in the book it is just constant, like the football boys were sitting around plotting how to mess with the rocket boys.

As a partial member of both cliques in high school I can attest that at the vast vast majority of all high schools, the "football boys" rarely spend more than 30 seconds thinking about the "rocket boys", at all.

There are many many other differences, some minor, some major, between the book and movie.

One amusing difference is Quentin: in the book, he was depicted as actually being fairly good-looking (as opposed to totally dorky in the movie), although he was still considered an egghead and was outcast from most of the kids.

Quentin in the book also constantly speaks in an affected "British" accent, using absurdly flowery condescending scientific jargon and being very snotty to pretty much everybody he meets, including his best friends. Easy to see how a kid like that would be left to eat his lunch by himself -- not to mention catching a knuckle sandwich or two.

reply

That's a good summary of the book vs. movie.

One thing I liked about the book is that it gives the back story of Coalwood. A rich person bought that huge plot of land where coal was found, and he built the mine, and the entire town from scratch: businesses, post office, doctor's offices, church, homes, etc. He was able to recruit people to move there to work.

I also liked how Homer described in such detail what life was like in Coalwood: that coal dust was everywhere, so everything outside had a layer of coal on it (housewives would try to clean the exterior of their homes but they would just get dirty again right away.) You'd have coal dust in your hair, under your nails, on your shoes, from any amount of time spent outdoors.

You must be the change you seek in the world. -- Gandhi

reply

Did you read the other two books in the "Coalwood Trilogy" yet?:
"The Coalwood Way": http://www.homerhickam.com/books/tcw.shtml
"Sky of Stone": http://www.homerhickam.com/books/sos.shtml

The whole series was a very good read. I couldn't put them down. But I got a feeling that Homer embellished a little bit more in the later books to make the storylines more entertaining.

He also wrote "We Are Not Afraid: Strength and Courage from the Town That Inspired the #1 Bestseller and Award-Winning Movie 'October Sky'": http://www.homerhickam.com/books/wana.shtml It's not a novel, but more like a self-help book. I have it but I haven't gotten around to reading it yet.

reply

I just read the book recently and was pleasantly surprised. I like the movie, but enjoyed the background of living in a coal town provided in the book. I thought Homers impression of Senator John Kennedy and other politicians was interesting. A must read!

reply