MovieChat Forums > Merlin (1998) Discussion > character conflict...hmm

character conflict...hmm


Hey i have been reading about the characters and i keep running into something that conflicts with this film.
Nimue and the Lady of the Lake are often said to be the same person. just that Nimue is another name, an also-known-as, for the Lady of the Lake.
in this film there are two distinct characters and they are very different.

i havent seen anything about Merlin loving a woman named Nimue.

dont get me wrong, i LOVE this film. im just throwing this out there because i got confused about characters.

oh also, Morgan le Fey is a different person than the woman who had Mordrid with Arthur. Sources say that Mordrids mother is Morgause, half sister to Arthur. Morgan is just Arthurs mean sister.

what i say is not fact and i could be wrong, so yea, i just thought it was interesting.

reply

It's all very simple. Nimue was actually a priestess training to be the next Lady of the Lake after Viviane. Morgan was, in fact, Mordred's mother. Morgause was Morgan's half sister and Mordred's foster mother (it was fairly common for high-born children to be fostered for their own protection).

I hope this helps.

reply

With no disrespect to deliadee, it seems like those descriptions are drawn from "The Mists of Avalon," which is a very contemporary reimagining of the Arthur story.

Because the story of King Arthur is a legend, there are numerous versions of the story. Depending on whose re-telling you consult (Chritien de Troyes, Thomas Malory, Alfred Lord Tennyson, TH White), there are going to be different details.

According to most versions, the name of the half-sister who sleeps with Arthur and births Mordred is Morgause, and Morgan le Fey is a seperate villainous half-sister. But "Merlin" is certainly not the first version of the story to combine the two characters.

In Malory's version, there are multiple Ladies of the Lake, though the story never differentiates between them. I cannot remember whether Malory's version names all of the different Ladies, but in Tennyson, it is Vivian who seduces Merlin and traps him under a rock (such as the way Nimue takes Merlin out of Arthur's story and traps him behind a rock -- though of his own free will -- in "Merlin"). I believe in White, it is Nimue who does it, but I cannot remember for sure.

Your best bet is to go read up on all of the different versions yourself. I would hardly call "The Mists of Avalon" a part of the Arthurian Legend canon, but that's just my humble opinion.

reply

Keep in mind: this is not intended to be a direct telling of the Arthur legend; it's a new retelling from a whole new perspective, so the writers are going to take liberties like that. This comes from a different direction, so certain details like that are not held sacred.

reply