Two cases I'm baffled by: the wig case, and "she is not my daughter"
A Jewish couple, Heidi and Mindi I believe. Something like that. They tried to fool the court with a cheap wig, pretending it was the expensive one. I did not see that coming. That was a powerful episode.
The case where the Trinidadian family (mom and daughter) was getting sued by the father, who claims the mother owes him money from decades ago. The daughter tells the judge that her father used to smoke crack cociane and the man, despite having DNA tests done that prove otherwise, keeps saying that she isn't his daughter. He definitely lived in "the Nile".