MovieChat Forums > Saving Private Ryan (1998) Discussion > Great start and [battle] ending, boring ...

Great start and [battle] ending, boring in between


The opening 26 mins are outstanding, as is the final battle.

For US flagwavers, no doubt every minute was a masterpiece, but the middle and saccharine finale were boring. Only Americans love the sickly-sweet stuff in lieu of genuine emotion well done.

reply

ONLY MORONS GENERALIZE AN ENTIRE COUNTRIES PEOPLES TO TRY AND SEEM SUPERIOR BY DICK SLAPPING A UNIVERSALLY LOVED FILM.

reply

Actually it's not universally loved. It has its moments but I never understood why people think so highly of it. Also, the opening which people always talk about has, I think, been bettered by other films in terms of realistic chaos and violence - Black Hawk Down and We Were Soldiers for example.

reply

Excuse my friend Kowalski, when he said that SPR is universally loved, he should have thought about you, because the fact that you don't like it means it is in fact NOT universally loved.

reply

Whilst that is technically correct I think it's also worth looking at the figures in Box Office Mojo. SPR, along with Forrest Gump, shows something like half the earnings are from the USA alone. I would suggest this shows it is of particular appeal to the American audience - and perhaps less so to the rest of the world?

reply

I think it's loved all over the world. I'm from Finland and this is one of my favourite films. And I know that critics and audiences love it here too. Just my two cents.

reply

That's fair enough and it's quite possible I'm in a minority here - guess it's just a film that doesn't work for me.

reply