MovieChat Forums > Saving Private Ryan (1998) Discussion > An Omaha beach film from the German pers...

An Omaha beach film from the German perspective?


I know this has been touched upon in previous posts, and I've greatly enjoyed such films as Stalingrad, (the original 1993 release, not the remake) and the Generation War series, but I've always thought it would be fascinating to see a D-Day beach invasion film from the German soldier's point of view. Maybe something akin to Letters from Iwo Jima; focusing on a small group of men as they build the beach defenses and prepare for the invasion. Attention paid to historical accuracy would of course be appreciated, but if this was a Hollywood film, I know that's not always possible, or even realistic considering the viewpoint.

I'd be interested to hear people's thoughts, or if they're aware of a film like this that already exists, as I always try to keep my eyes open for foreign made WW2 movies.

"Oh yeah, one more thing....where can I get a pizza?."

reply

Could be very good. Don't forget Das Boot. It was a German film telling a story from a German perspective.

TNSTAAFL

reply

Ah, yes! That was always one of my favorites, even when watching the five hour cut of the film. haha
I always pictured the HBO mini-series shows being a regular thing every few years or so, and focusing on different areas and events of the war, but that's just wishful thinking on my part.

"Oh yeah, one more thing....where can I get a pizza?."

reply

Naw...I'd prefer the Normandy campaign from these guys:


http://www.biblio.com/9781873376904

"PanzerMeyer" & his 1st SS PanzerKorp.






Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

There are a couple of movies, both released in 2011, that come to mind, although neither of them is about typical German infantrymen in the blockhouses on Omaha Beach.

The movie My Way http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1606384/combined follows two boys from Japanese-occupied Seoul, one a native Korean and the other the grandson of the Japanese military governor, who grow up as athletic rivals in track-and-field, then end up fighting, with the Japanese youth being the Korean youth's commanding officer, in the Japanese Army in Manchuria in the Sino-Japanese War. They are both captured, conscripted into the Chinese Army and sent to fight against the Soviets, are captured again and end up in a Siberian labor camp. They then escape from the camp after the Germans invade Russia, and decide the best route away from the Soviets is westward toward the German lines. They are then conscripted as HiWis into the Wehrmacht and end up building obstacles in Normandy and manning the defenses on D-Day. (They spend the movie changing hands from one totalitarian regime to another!) As improbable as this sounds, this is loosely based on a number of real life Korean HiWis who are taken prisoner by the US Army at Omaha Beach.

The movie Red Rose of Normandy http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1702587/combined follows the story of a Wehrmacht infantry captain disillusioned by his time on the Russian Front who is then wounded, and then while recovering is transferred to Field Marshal Rommel's headquarters in France while encountering an old flame who is in the German nursing service. They rekindle their romance only for him to learn that her father, a Communist sympathizer and recent middle-aged draftee into the Wehrmacht and assigned nearby, is under suspicion for being involved with the French Underground. After the father is caught red-handed, both the daughter and the captain are also arrested and are awaiting interrogation when D-Day arrives, and they use the confusion of the invasion to escape.

Both rather unconventional movies and made with a lot of CGI and otherwise low production values, but either could be the kind of movie you're looking for.

reply

Check out The Longest Day which is partly from the German perspective.



Working in the movie business since -92

reply