Question about pre WW2


During the 1930s when Hitler was Chancellor of Germany, did the world ever suspect anything more when the German soldiers were marching in organised fashion whilst carrying the swastika emblem? What about Hitler Youth?

I remember seeing the Soviet Army marching around similar to the Germans. Maybe it's just a show of might etc..

In Germany's case, were they seen only as 'patriotic military marches' only? Who could predicted
anything more, like the outbreak of World War 2?

reply

Some could see what was coming. Some couldn't. I don't think anyone who was not one of his/their direct victims foresaw the enormity, or sheer callousness, and pre-meditation of the Holocaust though.

TNSTAAFL

reply

Think about today and maybe you will get your answer. Today we have dictators in N. Korea and Russia, each making nuclear threats to other countries. Common wisdom would say that neither will follow through, nuclear war would likely destroy them. But you never know, do you? Only after the fact can you analyze what led up to a major conflict like that. We really have no way to know for sure if Russia will initiate a nuclear war, and if they do we have no idea when. Some wars have been started over comparatively minor things.

There certainly were clear signs in the 1930s and early 1940s that Nazi Germany posed a threat but most civilized countries do not have a policy of wiping out another country just because they appear to pose a threat. Otherwise N. Korea would already be decimated. Germany and Hitler could have decided to keep everything internally but they didn't. Then all hell broke loose.

..*.. TxMike ..*..

reply

The more probable reason is also that Britain & France were still feeling the effects of World War 1; After Verdun & the Somme, you'd think hard about acting too....And the US was the same-even though our casualties were much lower, more than a few officers & politicians recall expending tens of thousands of lives to conquer what amounted to a 'woodlot' and it wasn't a happy memory.





Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

That's a weighty question for a message board when historians and military analysts have devoted millions of pages to answer it.

Actually, per the Versailles Treaty and League of Nations the Allies had both the right and the obligation to prevent Germany from rearming and to react to Japan's aggression in Manchuria (not to mention Italy in Ethiopia) but they failed to act other than a few protests and a very weak embargo against Italy.

The two major allies, Britain and France, as forementioned, were exhausted and nearly bankrupt from WWI, plus the effects of the worldwide depression. Some also looked at a strong rearmed Germany as a bulwark against Russia; communism was regarded as a greater threat to world peace than fascism or naziism in the '20s and '30s. France's government was split between the right and left for most of those decades, and unfortunately Britain also had some pretty weak leaders, notably Baldwin and Chamberlain. Churchill, who did recognize the danger of Hitler and a rearmed Germany, was in the political wilderness until 1939; he was actually regarded as a dangerous political wild man by most of those in power.

Of course the USA was sitting on the sidelines. Roosevelt seemed to recognize the danger by the mid '30s, but between the problems faced at home and the isolationist sentiment of the majority of Americans, there wasn't much he could do until the war actually started, and by then it was too late.

Stalin apparently made overtures to the western powers, but they were either ignored or brushed aside. Allied diplomats sailed to Russia in the summer of '39, but they didn't even have the credentials to make a treaty; they were on their way back home when Ribbentrop flew to Moscow and signed the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact (and incidentally dividing Poland and placing the Baltic States in the Soviet zone of influence.

That's a nutshell account. I suggest reading William Shirer's "Rise and Fall of the Third Reich" if you want deeper understanding.

reply