Monte Cristo with a mask


Not to say this movie wasn't entertaining, but did anybody else feel this movie was a derivative of Monte Cristo? The progression of the story was so similar I was expecting to see Alexandre Dumas' name as a writing credit.

"You don't like Beethoven."
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=31535486

reply

You noticed. Clearly Monte Cristo was an influence. But, then, so was Robin Hood an influence -- he, too, goes away for a long time and comes back to seek justice in an alter ego. And if we're keeping score, Batman seemed to take an awful lot of cues from Zorro -- the secret cave, the animal identification, the black "steed," an so on. Storytelling is like that. And music. And art.

reply

[deleted]

Maybe Batman was inspired by the Shadow, but the Shadow had the power to cloud mens' minds and become invisible. Unless Batman has a special Bat-mindclouder on his utility belt, I think the inspiration stopped at 'they both fight crime'.

-"Denny Crane"

reply

Actually, I did read in a Bob Kane obituary that Zorro was a huge influence on Batman (hidden cave, secret identity, crimefighter), hence the film Mark of Zorro, which was what the Wayne family saw before Bruce's parents were gunned down. Of course with Zorro, there are definitely plenty of elements from Robin Hood and Monte Cristo. Even Don Diego's escape from prison in the movie was Edmond Dantes' plan.

reply

Everything I've read indicates Batman was indeed inspired by Zorro.

Zorro originally appeared in a pulp magazine, in a serial called "The Curse of Capistrano" (written by Johnston McCulley) in 1919. The creator of Batman, Bob Kane, was greatly inspired by the character. He has been quoted thus;

"Zorro's use of a mask to conceal his identity as Don Diego gave me the idea of giving Batman a secret identity... Bruce Wayne would be a man of means who puts on a facade of being effete. Zorro rode a black horse called Toronado and would enter a cave and exit from a grandfather clock in the living room. The bat-cave was inspired by this cave in Zorro. I didn't want Batman to be a superhero with super powers.... So I made Batman an ordinary human being; he is just an athlete who has the physical prowess of Douglas Fairbanks, Sr. [who starred in the silent film "The Mark of Zorro"], who was my all-time favorite hero in the movies." (From Robert and Katharine Morsberger's Introduction to the Penguin Classics edition of "The Mark of Zorro," page XI.)

Kane was so enthralled with the Zorro character that when he was a child in the Bronx, he and his friends called themselves "The Crusading Zorros" and wore black masks. The Batman story itself begins with Bruce Wayne seeing his parents brutally murdered after they had attended a showing of "The Mark of Zorro."

The most probable inspiration for Zorro was the novel "The Scarlet Pimpernel;" this seems to be the general conclusion in the articles I have read.

The film, "Mask of Zorro," is similar to "Monte Cristo," but it is not the original story and the whole "hero loses everything and seeks revenge but in the process heals himself and those he loves" plot-line is commonly used in film, theatre, and literature.

reply

Actually, Bob Kane has always been outward in saying that Zorro was his inspiration for Batman. I believe Mark of Zorro was even the film the Wayne family went to see when Bruce's parents were killed in the streets of Gotham.

reply

Zorro relies heavily on The Scarlet Pimpernel novel, and yes Batman is a modern adaptation of Zorro

reply

As they say, all the stories have been told before :) I noticed this as well, but Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite novels (along with Allende's Zorro), so this didn't bug me all too much.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah. But then again Ben-Hur is "Monte Cristo with a Chariot" so it's not like this was the first time! 

reply

The first time I saw it I felt like it was a combination of monte cristo, Indiana jones and Batman and boy did I love it.

"I really wish Gia and Claire had became Tanner" - Honeybeefine

reply