did they


did Paul D Garner and beloved have sex and if so isnt he her father?

reply

No Paul D. is not Beloved's father. Paul D is just Sethe's lover. The father of Sethe's 4 children is Baby Sugg's son, Halle.

reply

DarkAngel,

if Dad and Mom have sex, they can't have mom, right?

Beloved was the child of Sethe (Oprah) and her husband Halle. In the novel, Halle never made it to 124 Blueridge, and so 18 years later, Paul D. and Sethe started a relationship.

It is kinda disturbing though, b/c Paul D has sex with mother and (dead) daughter.

reply

Very disturbing!

reply

Not willingly, at least.


This time, Effie White's gonna win.

Whitney was wrong. Children are no longer the future.

reply