What Wishmaster do you think is the best?

Definitly the first one! Parts 2 and 3 were IMHO just awful (I haven't seen the 4th because of that)! But the first one I really enjoy every time I see it. Great performance by Divoff and superb SPFX. I especially enjoy the scene with the skeleton at the beginning of the movie which was somekind of a "horrific" hommage to Ray Harryhausen. Just great!!

The first 2 were the best but 4 has to rec credit for realizing how funny the first two were.

I've only seen the first two. I'm actually quite fond of the sequel. the gore was top-notch and andrew divoff as good as ever - only the religious imagery at the end got a bit tedious.
I play cards with J.D. Shelnut, chief of PO-lice! So kiss my ass, you old bastard!

1 and 2.
Andrew Divoff is the actor who makes the first two movies so good.

The first film is definitely the best but the second one is the most fun to watch because Andrew Divoff is in it a lot more. He's what really makes the first two films so entertaining. You can tell he had fun with the role and I had loads of fun watching him in it. Part 3 just sucked miserably. The acting, the special effects, and the storyline were all terrible which made the movie agonizing to sit through. The fourth film was a huge step up though because I liked the guy who played the Djinn in human form and the wishes/deaths were a lot more clever and amusing. I would watch a Part 5 for sure, especially if Divoff returned which would be awesome, but my expectations wouldn't be very high.

Horror_Metal

The first one has down is a classic. The second one was painful to watch. Too slow. Female lead was awful.Best parts of the film were the prison scenes because the Wishmaster was there!

Just for the record, I'm not a Dude, I'm a Dudette!

[deleted]

[deleted]