MovieChat Forums > The Truman Show (1998) Discussion > Gnosticism and the Postmodern Paradigm

Gnosticism and the Postmodern Paradigm


As the postmodern, liberal zeitgeist is underway, I find it interesting how so many films have inverted the traditional mindset. It is no surprise that most mainstream directors today hold an atheistic worldview. What is interesting to notice is the subtle, subliminal programming that occurs with films. The programming I am referring to is the inversion of reality into anti-reality, logic into anti-logic.

Upon scrutiny, what the viewer can actually notice is the promulgated myth of Gnosticism, as it applies to the liberal and postmodern paradigm. In order to understand this, we should first understand what Christianity, and its inverse—Gnosticism, are.

In Christianity, the story goes as follows: God created the Earth, with man and woman in it. As God is wholly good, his Creation was also wholly good. Lucifer, one of God's angels, opposed God, and during the War of Heaven, banished him—referring to him then as Satan—and his angels down to Earth, away from the gates of Heaven. Satan, masquerading under the guise of a serpent, tempted Eve to bite from the apple, granting Adam and Eve knowledge. From here, sin was born, and subsequently all of the foibles attributed to Earth are the result of this event. Satan, in Christianity, is the facilitator of the decay found in the temporal plane. The dichotomy here is that God exists in the realm of the spiritual, and Satan exists in the realm of physical. Ultimately, God, seeing Satan's influence, then incarnates as Jesus Christ, showing His creation the path towards salvation.

Christianity is the sphere of traditionalism, or objective truth. If we were to reduce Christianity to one word, it would be love. This notion of love as a divine emotion is what enables externalities to coalesce and bring that which is in the periphery into the center. We can refer to love as the unifying feature within its foundation, providing it with structure. This emotion is what gives integrity to its adherents. A contemporary model of this traditional and unifying force was seen within Protestantism, where the idea of a hard work ethic as a virtuous ideal led to capitalism, industriousness, and rapid civilizational advance in the form of technology.

Gnosticism, by contrast, inverts these principles. The Gnostic belief divided God into two beings—the highest, unknowable good God (the father), and the evil creator God (demiurge, also meaning creator in Greek). Gnostics saw the world as the product of evil, and therefore they viewed the temporal as a prison, from which the created must escape. Man contains the spirit, which he must free in order to be reunited with God the Father. Here, Lucifer is seen as the messenger from God the Father. He entered the paradise of the demiurge, disguised as a serpent, and granted the first man and woman knowledge from the fruit, which revealed to them that their ostensible paradise was in fact a prison, which the demiurge used for his entertainment. Later, Lucifer incarnated into Christ, providing the message of liberation from the material world and away from God the Creator.

Gnosticism's inversion of the traditional principles of good and bad fosters the overgrowth of liberal ideas, perfectly encapsulated in postmodernist thought. We can view Gnosticism as religious liberalism. The idea of individualism, the pursuit of experience, the notion that those on top are bad and those below are good, are subliminally depicted principles in the film medium.

The Truman Show can be viewed within the framework of Gnostic religion. The world Truman lives in is a paradise created by Christof (evil demiurge). Truman lives in a state of complete ignorance relative to the true state of the world outside him and Christof does not want him to acquire knowledge of the real truth. One day a spotlight with the inscription "Sirius" falls near Truman. Sirius is a star identified by the Gnostics with Lucifer carrying the light. The spotlight is the source of this light. In this way, the fall of the spotlight refers to the fall of Lucifer. After some time, Sylvia informs Truman that the world in which he lives is not real. Depending on the Gnostic teaching, Sylvia can symbolize Sophia, the spiritual Eve or the Serpent-Lucifer, penetrated into Paradise. After Truman learns about his deception, his goal is to resist the demiurge and exit from the world he created.

When individualism and the freedom for self-expression espoused in postmodernism is the highest goal in life, there is no way to provide cohesion for what is in the periphery. Without a unifying force, the parts which can compose the whole begin to decay, leading to dissolution. If everything is subjective, and there is no absolute truth, then ".... all who wander are lost," leading to the proliferating state of endlessly deranging narcissism at the forefront today.

reply

I thought Gnosticism was not a religion, but an acknowledgement that the existence of God can be neither proven nor unproven.

reply

Good question.

The term 'gnosis' (γνῶσις) derives from the ancient Greek word denoting 'knowledge'. Thus one who is a gnostic would be one who, quite simply, possesses knowledge.

Gnosticism was a religion and philosophical movement active between 200 BCE and 400 CE. Based on the idea of Gnosis, the Greek word for knowledge, it focused on salvation through the discovery and fostering of secret, inner knowledge.


It is a set of ideas and beliefs that originated within certain Christian and Jewish sects. While some consider it a heretical movement, it is theistic in nature, and aligns with certain Christian and Jewish sects. It contains elements of many religions, but is largely the opposite of traditional Christianity. Gnosticism has many different sects/denominations ((e.g., Manicheanism), much like any religion, each having their own nuances, but more or less inline with similar fundamentals.

A quick summary would be as follows:

Within Gnosticism, the world is seen as the product of a malevolent and imperfect creator (juxtaposed with Christian belief of omnipotence and perfection). It believes that in addition to God the Creator, there is another God above him. The idea of gnosis (knowledge through experience) is to understand this being. Finally, it believes that God the Creator (demiurge), is the product of a series of transgressions, emanating in the rise of this incomplete and impure being. The belief is that Sophia, attempting to create by herself, created the malformed demiurge.

The ideas of Manicheanism were espoused in season one of True Detective, particularly through Rustin Cohle. Gnosticism is merely an umbrella of philosophical and religious ideas that disagree with traditional religious beliefs.

Agnosticism is the belief that it is impossible to attain knowledge of God's existence or lack thereof. While they are secular, they acknowledge that perhaps God does exist, but there is insufficient information to confirm or deny such a claim.

I hope that helps.

Take care and stay safe.

reply

Yeah, agnsoticism is that I was thinking of. So, Gnosticism predates (or, at least, arose separately) from the Judeo/Christian tradition, yet it encompasses it? I suppose that's possible.

I wasn't aware of Gnosticsism, but I don't know if it's necessary for understanding this film. Seems like a perfect parallel of the story of The Garden of Eden.

reply

While there is quite a bit of shrouded mystery surrounding Gnosticism, it has no record of predating Christianity, as it believes in a Jesus and Lucifer. Zoroastrianism, one of the oldest religions and, sharing similarities with Manichaeism, was also considered a Gnostic religion. Contemporary Gnosticism follows a set of precepts, believing that everything associated with the material is evil, and therefore irrelevant. Christianity concerns itself with the Holy Trinity, so while it contains a spiritual component, its approach is more holistic (spirit, soul, body). Gnosticism gives primacy to the spirit, but its codex fails to nourish it. The spirit just is, and nothing matters.

What's interesting with Gnosticism, Hollywood, and liberalism is how the three relate. Within Gnosticism you have the eschewal of matter, believing that everything temporal is irrelevant, and that only the spirit matters. There is some validity, of course, in the idea that the spirit should be at the forefront, but the issue with Gnosticism is that this extreme disregard lends itself to liberalism. If your body is part of the material, then it is meaningless. If nothing in this world matters, you're free to explore endless pleasure, joy, and hedonism.

This orients with Hollywood's sensibilities perfectly, as Hollywood constantly promotes a message of dysfunction as normal (we live in an evil world, after all); sex, drugs, excess as acceptable (nothing in this world matters, only the spirit matters), Hollywood itself is seen as the epicenter of depravity. There is no morality, which is illustrated in films like Mulholland Drive and Neon Demon. The idea of a spirit that just is breeds determinism and complacency. You can see these principles play out in films like Snowpiercer, where the train represents the pre-set path, going around an evil and cold world, with no destination.

While not necessary for interpretations of films, an understanding may put broader concepts into perspective.

reply


I thought Babylon was the epicenter of depravity 😁

To be serious, Gnosticism most certainly IS a religion. It had a lot of influence on the development of Wicca, which is how I came across it. May I ask, have you studied theology formally, or are you self-taught, as I am? Either way impresses me. I can’t help being curious.

reply

Lately I have grown more and more interested in theology, philosophy, art, and spirituality. That said, I'm no theologian. I consider myself more of a dilettante than anything on the matter of most things, but I try to be as thorough as possible.

Stay safe.

reply

Yeah I think that's agnosticism. There's also something called the gnostic heresy, which may or may not be the same as what he describes here? My brain hurts. Ima have to come back and read this more slowly.

reply

I disagree.

reply

🤣

reply

:D

reply