MovieChat Forums > The Truman Show (1998) Discussion > A few questions about the set he lived i...

A few questions about the set he lived in...


Okay, so I know that this film was so pre-occupied with it's ideas that we never got to explore the technical side of Seahaven. I think that would've made the film easier to watch and a lot more praised than it currently is. Here are some flaws about the set built for Truman:

As we know, the sky is one large dome. When Truman's boat at the end puts a hole in the sky, we see that it's sort of made of like a plaster type material with painted clouds. However, this seems ridiculous because; how would they make sky cloudy, sunny, etc when the clouds are painted on there? How would they change? Not to mention, the sky/dome would need to change to mimic parts of the day like morning, and even sunlight. How? If the dome isn't made of pixels or whatever to display a 360 image, what is the plaster for? As we know, the sky is made of plaster, which means that something must be projecting images onto the surface. Where is this projector?

What was the sirius light for? Most likely the sun. So *sigh* if the sun was most likely a bright spotlight made by this projector, why do they have lights? Surely, this is pointless because when somebody would look up, they would see the lights that make the sun on the roof of the set, and they would probably resemble tiny dots. If the set is too far up for the lights to be visible, the you would still be able to see the shadows of the lights that aren't being used. It's kind of like looking at the top of a soundstage: You would be able to see the stage lights, right? Now, imagine that the soundstage roof is so high up. If those lights were turned on all the way up there, you would see clumps of lights. Imagine how many it would take to create one large sun.

How do they make rain? Where are these sprinklers and why can't we see them when we look up at the sky?

Making weather. Now, my question isn't so much how, but where? If they make a set sooo large it's visible from space, then surely, there must a LOT of engines and machines, and thousands of tonnes of heavy equiptment to mimic weather. Yet, all they do to control it, is create a few touch screen bars. WTF? If you had thousands of machines producing weather, you wouldn't just tap the screen, and they're all working?! There should be thousands of controls to control each aspect of the machine to create weather-and strong weather at that, which could potentially overheat and crash the machines from producing so much energy.

Come to think of it, this is a really stupid movie. Asked too many questions, didn't answer any of them.

reply

I just chalked it up to it being a movie so best not to ask a lot of questions about things like this. They did the same thing in the hunger games. They could create a huge amount of fire/ fireballs, killer fog, blood tidal wives and lightning all from the control room. It's fantastical, don't put too much thought into it. Also, it is true that knowing exactly how everything worked would have bogged the movie down. It's just there to influence Truman's life and make a good story, and it does that. You don't need to know the complex inner workings of it.




Mirror mirror on my floor. Am I the prettiest at the store?

reply

They could create a huge amount of fire/ fireballs, killer fog, blood tidal wives and lightning all from the control room. It's fantastical, don't put too much thought into it. Also, it is true that knowing exactly how everything worked would have bogged the movie down.


But The Hunger Games was naturally - a Sci Fi film. Keep wanting your morning dew because The Hunger Games showed the skeleton of the technical process of it all. Blitz the screen with fancy holograms and BOOM everything's explained without actually explaining anything -.-.

reply

Interesting that the OP commenter complained about some things that are in fact theoretically explainable (as some of the responses above show), but, in spite of his thinking he's smart because he needs them explained, he missed *much more obvious* problematic things (and somehow he thought Sirius was the sun?! lol): the phases of the moon were often dead wrong, and very obviously so. For instance, at one point we see a sunset and the moon in the sky at the same time, and it's extremely obvious that the dark shadow side of the moon is VERY wrong for the position of the sun! Truman would have to be real dope to not recognize that, and the engineers who designed the dome and its effects would have to be real dopes, too. I must admit I do wonder why the filmmakers of this movie intentionally (obviously) made that particular "mistake".

A simple telescope or maybe even just binoculars would *immediately* prove to Truman that his world is unquestionably fake.

Not only did this thread's OP commenter not mention these *much more obvious* things, but they're all basically irrelevant anyway and have little to nothing to do with the quality of this truly great film.

reply

the very important thing you miss is, he would have to know how the real phase of the moon looked like. to him, whatever was shown and made in the dome was the "reality".

if the creator had a purple color moon instead of white from the beginning of the show(his birth), it would never appear to be out of the ordinary to Truman.

he is being carefully monitored at all times, and surely any quests to know about the reality of the universe would be stopped instantaneously.

reply

My question, for sh*ts and giggles, is regarding the sprinklers. How in the hell would they be able to pump enough water up to the top of that enormous dome in order to actually recreate rain? I mean the mechanical means just to do that would be absolutely mind-boggling. I remember a documentary about 9/11 where one the firefighters on the scene was overheard saying: "how the *beep* are we gonna get water up that high?". That being said, I would love to hear an explanation lol

"Let's get out of here before one of those things kills Guy!"

reply

The short answer to all the questions posed in this thread: a wizard did it.

The longer answer: nothing we see is literally impossible from an engineering or physics perspective, just prohibitively expensive and complicated. They're not exceeding the speed of light or operating perpetual motion machines. They're building giant domes (domes are a thing in the real world, and are actually better suited as megastructures than virtually any other design), creating artificial lights (you're probably within a few feet of one right now, and much more powerful ones are available, so there's no reason the sun has to be a bunch of lights clustered together), spraying water from a height (something that happened the last time you took a shower), moving water (hell, a basic Jacuzzi can do that), painting matte images (like painters have been doing for centuries, albeit not for movies until the last century or so), and so forth. Clearly somebody put in the effort, and, since this isn't our world, clearly the effort paid off, since the Truman Show has endured and prospered for thirty years in this world.

As for the complicated weather controls, this is a closed environment. There's no reason to control every single variable individually every time they want to do something. Instead, it makes far more sense to create programs that implement a certain set of conditions. (For instance: Light rain, 12 mph winds from the west, with variable intensity squalls in a progressive pattern, for example. Press "1" and you have it all with a single tap of the screen.) You are only guessing at how the energy is achieved and discharged. In this world of giant domes and billions of people watching a reality with fanatical devotion, one might decide that the show has a dedicated small nuclear reactor. Or whatever. As I said, it's all just basic engineering, and when you're dealing with the scale of a dome big enough to cover an entire town, an island, and a fair-sized bay, you're dealing with distances that don't lend themselves to careful examination. Next time it's a sunny day outside, go look up at the sun and ask yourself if you'd be able to make out details up that high under the glare of a light as bright as the sun.

reply

"If the dome isn't made of pixels or whatever"

Um, pixels do not exist in the real world. You can't have a dome made of pixels. You can have a screen that's dome-shaped, you can have millions of LEDs (which would not be bright enough to mimic sun, moon or even stars believably, but then again, why would Truman need to know about any of these, they could just switch on and off some bright lamp in the middle of the dome, Truman doesn't know any better, how would he know it's not realistiC?)..

..but you can't make things out of pixels in the real world, because pixels DO NOT EXIST in the real world, they are NOT a substance, they are NOT a material, they are literally NOTHING.

They can only exist as 'unreal projections by display devices', that's all. They absolutely need a display device to be seen, otherwise they exist as DATA ONLY inside computers and processors (and GPUs and..)

So, please learn logic before writing posts about movies - it's hard to trust someone's logic that doesn't even understand what pixels are, and then brushes this off by offering us the intelligent explanation of "whatever".

Nothing can be built of 'whatever', as it's just an abstract mental construct, a pointer to absolutely nothing.

You couldn't bring yourself to mention LED lights or flexible display devices or anything? Really?

reply

We do all of these things in movie studios right now. Why is it so implausible to think they couldn't do it in a dome

reply