MovieChat Forums > Titanic (1997) Discussion > What if 'Jack' was instead a 'Jane'? Yes...

What if 'Jack' was instead a 'Jane'? Yes, true forbidden love. A lesbian affair


A tomboy who travels the world, passing as a boy when needed, but actually a 32 year old woman, with a thing for redheads.

She saves Rose from jumping off the ship. Everyone thinks that "Jack" is a boy, no older than 16, but she turns up to the thank you dinner in a beautiful dress and her boyish hair styled back.

Rose can't take her eyes off of her. How can she look hot both as a boy and a woman?

Of course, she goes back to her tomboy look, which Rose is also crazy about, never before knowing that a woman could convey masculine energy and put moves on girls.

She draws her naked, does her in the luggage hull, and gets in trouble for it.

"Forget this lesbian affair, Rose! You are to marry me!" yells Cal.
"But I love her!" Rose protests.
"Do you really think you could have a good life with her? She's nothing but a vadabond!"

In this story, when "Jack" dies, she gets off the wood, sinking to the bottom with her.

Now that is true love.

reply

I would probably watch that. And I would probably like it more than I liked Cameron's Titanic, of which I'm not a fan.

reply

Thank you, my first fan-fic lesbian tale.

reply

Well, that might have been more interesting than the boring story they actually filmed! And the film would have benefitted from different casting, too, I've never liked Leo one bit!

Although I disagree about the end of the story. The single best moment in the movie is when Rose decides that even though she's lost everything that ever mattered to her and is about to die along with everyone else, she is going to fucking LIVE! And that's something that could have been shown in the post-script, pictures showing Rose living her life with girlfriends and boyfriends and eventually a spouse, because she'd finally seized life by the... short hairs.

reply

[deleted]

I'd say

YOU really need to go out and get a Fg life

reply