MovieChat Forums > Ta'm e guilass (1997) Discussion > Too boring and vacuous (spoilers)

Too boring and vacuous (spoilers)


So ugh, a man drives around looking for someone to burry him after he commits suicide. Apparently he can't just die like a man and conveniently he doesn't have a single friend who could help him, so he has to drive around all day begging strangers, who all happen to be moralists who turn down his large sum of cash.

Obviously this is a contrived set up for some sort of philosophical discussion on suicide, amirite?

Wrong, instead we just listen to mostly banal chatter for the entire film, with little-to-no intellectual merit behind it, and watch the man driving around leisurely. There is unfortunately no discussion whatsoever as to the man's motives, he refuses to reveal that, and the film is completely vacuous as a result. All characters he talks to up until the final one are complete write-offs who'd might as well discuss the weather. Finally someone gives us some remotely interesting arguments, but then the protagonist suddenly stops talking altogether. He goes through some weird actions obviously designed to tell us he's having second thoughts about it, and then an obscure ending is tacked on and the credits roll.

And it is NOT overly beautiful (it's OK, but certainly nothing special).

Disappointing. Another below par criterion release....



~ Observe, and act with clarity. ~

reply

That pretty much sums up my thoughts on the film.

reply

The man's acting is remarkable. The realism of his disillusionment with life as a member of the upper middle class is strikingly realistic, as are his interaction with people he picks up.
I believe this film could be a comment on capitalism and dynamics + ethics between the employer and employee. It's notable that most of the people refusing are the young,the one who has compassion is the elderly man as he realizes the nature of life- he tries to pull the depressed man back to earth through the cherries,yetis smart enough to know this man is too far gone to be saved- he requires a force beyond earthly dimensions I.e. God. Thus, I thunk it's a film about an atheist intellectual finding God again,he has to be reborn and he is reborn by escaping the bounds ofthe narrative- the message of the film seems to suggest that life is just a larger role we all play.
The military boy who is very kind and soft spoken was a fascinating character. It's the authenticity that is amazing. This film isnt supposed to have "traditional Hwood dramatic acting, it's much closer to cinema verité

reply

[deleted]