MovieChat Forums > The Horse Whisperer (1998) Discussion > Can a horse really recuperate after bein...

Can a horse really recuperate after being injured?


Can a horse really recuperate after being injured in real life?

If so, why does everyone say you have to shoot a horse if it's injured?


http://www.happierabroad.com - Discover Global Dating Solutions!

reply

Absolutely. It depends on the extent of an injury and where as to whether a horse need be euthanized. This instance IMO was close to being to that point.

reply

Vet medicine for big animals has progressed to the extent that it is not always necessary to euthanize a horse. However, that said, it is also extremely expensive and the facilities that could treat big animals are not numerous. Also, if the animal is a valuable horse for breeding purposes usually, the chances of owners putting out the money to save a severely injured horse is a significant factor. Insured horses such as show horses and race horses at the top end are more likely to be sent to such hospital facilities. Working cow ponies and backyard recreational horses are less likely to get the full treatment that say, Barbaro received when he broke his leg. In the end, even the best surgery and equine facility in the country couldn't save the Kentucky Derby winner.

-- Ew lover, you gonna make me clutch my pearls --

reply

WHERE WAS THIS FILMED?? MONTANA??

reply

YES!! SOME OF IT ANYWAY!!:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119314/locations

PS: YOU SHOULD START A NEW TOPIC INSTEAD OF POSTING YOUR QUESTION IN THIS ONE!!

Peace, Love, and

reply

wow u are the imbd. police person

reply

No. That would be an administrator.

I was only trying to help you get some more exposure (and answer your question—you're welcome, by the way), and this is the gratitude I get? Remind me never to do you any more favors. But I still feel pity for you.

Peace, Love, and

reply

a. i didnt know how to start a new topic.
b. thank u
c. u are the police i see!! LOL

reply

Can a horse really recuperate after being injured in real life?

If so, why does everyone say you have to shoot a horse if it's injured?


Generally, the shooting of a horse usually refers to when a horse has a broken leg. This is because it is complicated to heal a horse's broken leg due to the fact that they are large animals that spend a lot of time on their feet.

Although pinning the broken bone isn't that hard, the liklihood of the horse re-injuring the leg is high due to the fact that they don't understand what is going on, and thus panic. Even when you do prevent this, complications can occur in the other legs because the horse now has one less able-bodied leg to support its weight.

reply

rarely hoist the flag did, but exception. poor barbaro was worked on for 7 months sadly died

reply

Shantaar-2;
Your "exception" is described in the last paragraph of the last OP's entry - that complications from too much weight bearing on the other legs, in Barbaro's case Laminitis. Horses are basically ambulating on tiptoe, on one "nail" as it were. Are you familiar with old torture method of slivers under the nails of people? That's tantamount to what horses feel when the hoof wall separates from the internal structure, and that' s the only nail they have to support their weight. In addtion to the added weight on the remaining hooves, stress alone can cause Laminitis, and putting them in a sling can take the weight off the hooves, but causes great stress by the horse feeling trapped, as that are primarily a flight animal.
Barbaro did not die from his injuries, but was humanely euthanized when the Vets and the owners saw the painful effects of his Laminitis which was progressing beyond intervention.
Horses these days are not shot (either with a traditional bullet out a retractable bolt pistol), but are given an intravenous injection with a veterinary euthanasia solution (basically a quick barbiturate overdose).
These days horses can be recovered in a water bath, to reduce and even eliminate the reciprocal injuries upon recovery. The recovery of Ruffian, the filly that match-raced Foolish Pleasure back in the 70's and shattered her right front fetlock (ankle), is what ended her life - she apparently reshatteted her fetlock and freshly broke her elbow in the thrashing. She would not have survived a second prolonged surgery, so they euthanized her. Would that they had a water recovery unit...

reply

Kind of late to the game...But I spent a lot of this summer at UC Davis's Large Animal Hospital, and I was AMAZED at the lengths some of their clients went to to heal their horses. There was a stallion in a sling with a broken leg that was there from May until we finally brought our critter home in September. I have no idea if he even left or survived. When people have put thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, into a horse, they'll oftentimes go to any lengths, even to the detriment of the animal. Hell, I spent $9K to heal up a free, rescued alpaca. So it all depends on the owner and the injury to the animal, as well as what facilities are nearby.

And the previous poster is right-on; it all depends on the type of injury because equines need all four legs to support their weight, whereas other animals, like goats and cows, who support their weight on their front legs, can live with a missing hind leg. There are even vets working on prosthetics for equines. I know of one donkey who has a prosthetic leg and seems to be doing very well.

I have three horses, two Arabians and one Thoroughbred, and they're all over twenty. They were all rescued, even though at one time they were very valuable horses. Because they are 20, 23, and 33, respectively, if one of them broke a leg, I would call the vet out to euthanize immediately. My attitude is different, though, because I do rescue. I consider where funds should best be spent, and many times, giving an older or severely injured animal a dignified, peaceful death in their own pasture is better than putting it through extremely stressful (and expensive) transport and veterinary intervention. That money can be spent rescuing another horse or horses from a neglect or kill-auction situation.

reply

May I just say; you have a lot of courage, and a lot of compassion.

One doesn't get that way in the beginning. You must have had to make many heart and head-guided decisions--that you wished dearly you didn't have to make.

Just as one person, I'm glad those under your care have you. So many are lost; at least some are recognized, known, cherished.

Thank you.

reply