MovieChat Forums > Gattaca (1997) Discussion > Gattaca (1997) was a low key/understated...

Gattaca (1997) was a low key/understated Fascist nation/society


Even though it’s not explicitly stated and it doesn’t have the traditional hallmarks of a Fascist government, I believe it was meant to portray the Fascism of the future.

Not the clunky 20th century version with totalitarian demagoguery and guys in military uniforms shouting from balconies. But a much more sleeker and subtle kind. A high-tech and a more patient approach to implementing Fascism.

The kind where they nudge, prod and pressure (via discrimination) the population to accept eugenics. Eugenics that clearly create on average a healthier, stronger but also a more grateful population. If you’re healthier and happier as a result of such policies, you express your gratitude with…loyalty of course. Loyalty to the system that freed you from the shackles of genetic diseases and the socioeconomic burdens that come with them.

Loyalty to a system that has practically eradicated most issues that have plagued societies in the past. Gattaca has clean streets, little to no public disorder, and what looks like a decent economy for most of its citizens with infrastructure that is sleek and futuristic.

Gattaca is Fascism of the 21st Century…and beyond.

reply

I think you're right. Same as with Starship Troopers...
https://moviechat.org/tt0120201/Starship-Troopers/5f43b611ebe2ab1330b6ff9c/Other-depictions-of-functional-authoritarian-societies-in-film
Someone even mentioned 'Gattaca' as an example of "functioning crypto-fascist society" in the thread above.

reply

The elite in Gattaca found out how to implement Fascism without raising too much suspicion.

reply

Or it just eliminated most of it's enemies and has the population so under control that there simply isn't any room (or will) for dissent anymore. Much like things would probably have been a 100 years after the Third Reich had won and managed to implement all of its policies.

reply

Again nothing to suggest that.

I think the government and society in Gattaca came to the realization that having a well ordered, high IQ population that was healthy and productive was the best way to achieve long term prosperity.

And it showed looking at Gattaca. A country with a high tech economy and sleek infrastructure.

Yes it was Techno-Fascism for a lack of a better term. But it worked.

reply

Great post. Will have to revisit this film soon

reply

It’s an underrated sci-fi gem.

reply

Gattaca isn't fascist.

The government doesn't need, the movie didn't show it either, to "nudge, prod and pressure" people to "accept eugenics." The movie even mentioned the government had laws against gene discrimination.

If the technology existed, 99% of parents would voluntarily use it on their children. Every parent wants children to be smart, good-looking, tall… perfect.

reply