MovieChat Forums > Alien Resurrection (1997) Discussion > Alien 3 was the ending, Resurrection is ...

Alien 3 was the ending, Resurrection is an expansion pack for morons.


https://www.amazon.com/Alien-3-Special-Sigourney-Weaver/dp/B004FGDMK0

reply

By the same token Alien was the ending, and Aliens was the expansion pack for morons.

Or Aliens was, and Alien 3 was...etc etc

They are all closed narratives, that the next sequel re-opens.

Just because you didn't like what they did in 4 doesn't make it any less valid, or part of the canon, than Alien 3 or Aliens. There was no mention of a prison planet in Alien, there was no mention of a human colony in Alien.

reply

"There was no mention of a human colony in Alien"....the human colony didn't exist yet; Alien was 57 years before all that. Also, why would the prison planet be mentioned in the first Alien?

reply