Harvey, Josh or Aaron?


Which one of these guys did you like the best?

For me personally, I really liked Harvey the best since he is always shown to be so nice and understanding of Sabrina's feelings and I just loved his goofy personality! I didn't care for Josh too much since he seems to be a jerk towards Sabrina at times and Aaron they just abruptly introduced him at the last second.

reply

Harvey, it was always Harvey for me. He was sweet, handsome, and always cared about Sabrina. One of the best things about the final seasons was Harvey knowing she was a witch and loving her for who she is.

reply

I also loved the fact that in the final seasons, Harvey knew that Sabrina was a witch and still helped her out when she needed it. It pretty much made it clear that Harvey and Sabrina were meant to be!

reply

This again was no contest. Josh was annoying and Aaron was in like 4 episodes. How could you not like Harvey?

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

*10 episodes

"you thought it was me gnawing on the passengers? nah, I'm a vegetarian."

reply

Wow that's why I said "like" since obviously he couldn't have been in only 4 episodes unless it was literally 1) meet 2) date 3) engage 4) wedding. I was obviously pointing out it was a short time, which is why I put a low number. It was still less than 3 months for the timeline, which is not anywhere near enough time to develop a character enough for an audience to be emotionally invested.

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

There's No Need For Sarcasm.I.emotionally invested.they were a.cute couple.
Spacebar.doesn't.work!

"you thought it was me gnawing on the passengers? nah, I'm a vegetarian."

reply

I really can't bother to read someone who is too disrespectful or stupid to type correctly.

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

You're.the.stupid.one.I.told.you.my.space.bar.is.not.working.should've.read.the.full.way.through.

"you thought it was me gnawing on the passengers? nah, I'm a vegetarian."

reply

Harvey. josh and aaron are both hot, but she is soul mates with harvey.

reply

Harvey was great.

Josh makes me projectile puke. He treated Sabrina without respect.

Aaron is a Josh that additionally is also too old.

---
A gentleman will not insult me, and no man not a gentleman can insult me.

reply

Josh makes me projectile puke. He treated Sabrina without respect.

Aaron is a Josh that additionally is also too old.


Disagree with the last part. Aaron treated Sabrina far better than Josh did. He was also a lot more understanding with Sabrina than Josh was (prime examples being: being understanding of her friendship with Harvey, being understanding with the many times that she held up the wedding due to her conflicted feelings, even being understanding with Sabrina calling off the wedding and riding off into the sunset with Harvey). While of course I love Harvey with Sabrina most of all, Aaron wasn't a bad guy he was just the wrong guy for Sabrina. He wasn't a cad like Josh was.

Ex-girlfriend, you can't have him!: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TThHPHU4oJY

reply

I liked Josh the most as a separate character since Harvey was basically set up to be perfect for Sabrina and Aaron just seemed to come along so they could give Sabrina a love interest. That being said I liked Harvey and Sabrina as a couple over the other options.

reply

Okay, thats perfectly possible, I havent watched much of season 7, I think its absolutely horrible, except for the last episode - so my impressions of Aaron are actually pretty superficial.

---
A gentleman will not insult me, and no man not a gentleman can insult me.

reply

Harvey. Josh was kind of meh. Aaron, well, I was just rewatching some of the later episodes and there's one where Aaron takes care of Salem while Sabrina is away? And he treats Salem horribly! Locks in him a little cage and everything! I realize that Salem can be a bit of a pest but man, anyone who treats animals like that is not cool in my book. I mean, even if he doesn't like cats, he's Sabrina's pet. You'd think he'd treat Salem well for that reason alone, if nothing else.

Harvey took good care of Salem when he watched him, he was always looking out for Sab and he still treated her great after finding out she was a witch (after the initial probs, that is). He just wanted her to be happy. So yeah, gotta go with Harvey.



It's not about who you are or your fancy car. You're only ever who you were.

reply

I think she should of ended up with Aaron! I do like her and harvey but I felt it was a high school relationship that probably should've ended awhile after high school. it just sets up this unrealistic expectation that high school relationships last, idk, I really think she should of married Aaron.

"you thought it was me gnawing on the passengers? nah, I'm a vegetarian."

reply

Harvey was the best for her. Josh seemed more like the rebound guy. Aaron looked so old and seemed more like a father figure.

reply

WTF

You dont want Sabrina to be happy because it sets a bad example ?!?!?!?!?

Besides, some of these relationships work pretty well. In fact, quite a lot of them do. I can name half a douzen people from my schoolclass alone who are now married to the girl- or boyfriend they had back then.

---
A gentleman will not insult me, and no man not a gentleman can insult me.

reply

I.never.said.that.twist.my.words.if.it.makes.you.happy.
That's.cool.though,It.just.seems.rare!

"you thought it was me gnawing on the passengers? nah, I'm a vegetarian."

reply

[...] I felt it was a high school relationship that probably should've ended awhile after high school. it just sets up this unrealistic expectation that high school relationships last [...]

Your words. Not mine. Not twisted. Thats exactly what you said. Thats what I answered to.

---
A gentleman will not insult me, and no man not a gentleman can insult me.

reply

[deleted]

Harvey, of course. He was so cute and lovable.

reply