I think that a “realistic” atmosphere is beneficial to the effect of the funny scenes. Terry Gilliams said in the Monty Python autobiography that for Monty Python and the Holy Grail he wanted to create as authentic a dirty medieval atmosphere as possible, which is then made absurd by the funny scenes.
I’m sure the scene with Jonathan and Lucy (“I’m British” – “So are these!”) works better because there is a somewhat creepy, atmospheric scene before it (the shot of the statue seemingly shouting “Jooonathan”) that could well have come from a real scary movie. When a film constantly tries to be funny, it’s rather tiring.
The scene with the blind hermit from Young Frankenstein has a similar structure: first the camera moves through his hut while you hear sad music. This scene is not funny at all. Brooks builds up a “realistic” atmosphere here, only to make fun of it in the scene between the hermit and the creature. If the scene in which the hermit is introduced already contained gags, the effect of the following funny scenes would not be so great.
reply
share