MovieChat Forums > Braveheart (1995) Discussion > Edward I only needed assassin crackshot ...

Edward I only needed assassin crackshot archers?


In the melée of brutal battle, if Edward had hired the 10 best Welsh/English archers to wait and look for Wallace either at the beginning of battle, or at the end if he insisted upon chasing people off-field, bingo!

reply

Do you realise how difficult it is to aim for a whole crowd of people when you're being attacked and possibly under a hail of arrows yourself? LET ALONE seek out a single individual who is running around, ducking, and being obscured by others in front of him constantly?

If the target was by himself in a field or in the woods with his pants down taking a shit, then yes, you'd stand a better chance, but not right smack bang in the middle of a hectic bloody battlefield.

As ridiculous as this NON-history action movie is, even the producers wouldn't be so stupid as to do this.

reply

Yes, I do realise. Obviously in melee's it would be awkward, but it's not as crazy as it sounds, if Hollywood can do Robin Hood type accuracy, then pre-battle potshots aren't beyond the realm?

reply

Agreed, they could snipe from anywhere in range.

And in the film - didn't Edward aim at EVERYONE??

reply

How stupid is the OP? Next he'll be asking why the Welsh bowmen don't aim straight ahead instead of upwards like they do!

reply

How stupid is AMJF? next he'll be attempting to criticise something that doesn't make sense or have balls, like him/her/itself!

reply