MovieChat Forums > The Hudsucker Proxy (1994) Discussion > One part does not make sense

One part does not make sense


Why would the owner of the toy store drastically reduce the price of the hula hoop over the course of the first day he carries it BEFORE SCHOOL EVEN LETS OUT FOR THE DAY?! You know, for kids, idiot!

We're Evergreen Old Boys, remember?

reply

Because this film is, among many other things, a campy satire about the consumer world.

reply

LOL! Where did it say he did it during the first day? Nowhere. It's all in your head....



RIP Ian....

reply

yeah, I always assumed each reduced sticker was a another day.

reply

One day!!!???

They're trying to let us believe that this whole story took place in... what? 100 minutes! Tcha!

reply

The whole scene was an extended montage, meant to telescope time, a good example of "cinematic time".

But in any case, why should anyone look for physical "reality" in a film so clearly of the mind? It's like complaining that the sets didn't look like New York.

"Sometimes you have to take the bull by the tail, and face the truth" - G. Marx

reply

pointlessly nit-picky. I agree with the others who explained that the Coens employed that common cinematic device used to telescope time.

reply

a) thats the part that does not make sense to you? you must have gave up before the ending lol.

b) yeah that could have been a week, could have been an entire season. i for one thought it was beautiful detail in the film.

reply

Actually the part that didn't make sense was the fact that the board members didn't stick to their own plan. They installed a moron as company president, with the intention of buying up all of the outstanding stock when the price was really low.

So why did the board members sell all of their stock, when the price was low? I thought the general rule of business was "Buy low, sell high", not the other way around!

reply

They sold when it was high, expecting to buy (much more as Hudsucker's own stock was available on 1.1.1959.) But the success of the hula hoop meant that the stock went even higher than the high point where they sold.

reply

Actually the part that didn't make sense was the fact that the board members didn't stick to their own plan. They installed a moron as company president, with the intention of buying up all of the outstanding stock when the price was really low.

So why did the board members sell all of their stock, when the price was low? I thought the general rule of business was "Buy low, sell high", not the other way around!

reply

From what I remember, they said that if they sold it they'd make money, but then the stock would be too high to buy back then, so they tried lowering it so when it went public on Jan 1st they could swoop right in and buy it back for cheap, then put things back to normal and make money again.

reply

They were trying to create a selling panic to make the stock drop further so they could buy back more.

reply